Customer Reviews Madewell Whisper Cotton Turtleneck

Sizing is strange with large neck and torso but tight arms

Eh. The material is thin and on the soft side but runs think and wrinkles easily

The size is fine. Fabric is very thin and is not attached to the neck straight on-grain. (Very obvious because of the heathered color.) This makes it not hang correctly (pulls down on the lower side of the "stripe".) This is makes it very cheap-looking. It's unfortunate because the color is nice and hard to find.

Good quality. Well made and true to size. It is a nice weight........not too heavy, not too flimsy. Runs large so I will be returning it.

Great Ashen silver color. Fits true to size. Not too fitted, but not loose and sloppy. Order your usual size.

This top is well made. The material is a bit stretchy and clingy for my taste. It runs a bit small.

Terrible quality & super short in length. Returned. (I do love Zappos tho-great customer service!)

Color ok but quality terrible . Cheap,

Great layering piece! Lightweight and easy to mix and match with outer heavier layers.

It fits true to size. It is a light weight shirt which is awesome as I can wear with a wool sweater or lighter sweater. I like the fact it is a little longer so it stays tucked into my jeans.

Perfectly light wear for layering! You can wear this lightweight turtleneck as your 1st protective layer for cooler weather. The material feels like cotton and keeps you feeling dry when your body makes thermal adjustments to different layers and external temperatures.

This top is exactly what I was looking for !! Light weight soft cotton with a turtle neck that isn’t to tight on your neck. I ordered all 3 colors! They are perfect for layering. I wear them with a t-shirt over it & don’t have to take a jacket into cold offices, restaurants etc. So happy & comfortable when out and about wearing this.

Loose fit super relaxed and comfy

Its a thin shirt but its great for layering and just a minimalist with a classic style. A staple in my wardrobe already!

Fit is great Quality is great Size is roomier than I thought which is a bonus

Great

Roomy fit and very thin fabric. So comfortable! But definitely not a warm T-neck. You’ll have to layer when it’s cold outside!

Cute. Great color. Thin. A bit short

This is a win. Basic wardrobe building block - meets expectations!

The fabric is so thin you can almost see right through it. I usually like Madewell products, but this turtle neck is really flimsy.

Very small for X-Large and shrunk even more after washing