Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy Vintage Slub Polo

Very comfortable.

I have two of these shirts, and unfortunately the reviews came true for me. Within months both of them had holes in them, and one had loose threads while my other J&M shirts, t-shirts, etc. all last for years. Sad to say my search for the perfect polo continues.

Shirt did not wash well. Needed a lint brush to smooth out the fabric

I liked the shirt, until I wore it. The hem lines frayed immediately on the first wear on 2 shirts. So I returned them. The fit and fabric felt great. But something is off with the construction.

These shirts are going back - the quality is just not good

Close to t shirt fabric weight. Not fitted for slim build. White isn't a bright white.

The fabric is about the weight of a t shirt. Color is as shown. Stitching is nice. Not a fitted cut for slim.

I will stick to buying j&m shoes not clothes

I purchased several of the shirts based on my long positive experience with J/M. Almost immediately the quality level came into view. Thin material, picks in the shirts, thread unraveling, even one shirt coming with a small hole in the front. This was a very disappointing product not worth, even at a special price. I would have been just as satisfied if I through the purchase money into the street.

Unfortunately the after one wash the collar was messed up

I have purchased many items from this store and over $500 just today locally. However this shirt offers very poor value. I bought another 7 in total but one season is their limit. They form holes and run from no apparent damage.Today I bought XC 4 so hoping for better life. If you are happy with limited use and a great look go ahead !

Like the look, but hitches begin in the fabric with very light wear. Some polos are made with a sulfur based dye, the smell of which does not come out with repeat washes. Would buy again except these issues will prevent me from doing so.

See Pictures.

I loved the look of these shirts as well as the various colors they come in. They are very soft and feel great but the collars start wearing away quickly. I bought 5 of these shirts last summer and the collars started wearing away after the second or third time.

Looks and feels great but collar shows wear quickly.

I love these shirts . Look great and feel great. Only issue is over time they get holes around seems. So they really don't hold up over the long term

I ordered 4 of these shirts and everyone of them have like snagged and frayed the first time I have worn them and the stitching is coming apart. I would not buy again.

Shirt picked very easily. Only got one wear out of it. Very disappointed in the quality.

Fit is terrible. Collar is too high and stiff.

Reached out to customer support...no response. Cannot wear it again.

Ordered these in two colors - Very disappointed. They run small but worse, the colars pill and fray along the neck-line. The look like crap after just wearing it a few times and washings.

The shirt color looks like a worn out old shirt. When my shirts turn grey from Black I die them or give them away. This thing showed up looking and feeling like an old worn out shirt. I can't wear it places where I wanted to wear it. It's a house shirt now.

These shirts have a neck opening that is so tight that I can't wear them. I wear a xl and my neck is about 16 1/5 on a normal shirt. The material and construction seems good but would never buy another from you company. Going to donate these shirts. I just bought some golf shoes and pants from your local store and very pleased with the quality. Disappointed with the shirts because they were not cheap.

It roughs off on collars due to beard and developed holes in armpit very quickly.

I have purchased 8 shirts total. Each one of them (8) develops a hole at the bottom, button line where the fabric meets the seem. Disgusted to think I paid so much for such poor quality. Do not purchase. It's not just an isolated incident. All 8 shirts ruined after a couple of washes. Johnston and Murphy is known for better quality than this.