Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy Vintage Slub Polo

Love the design and colors.

Shirt is extremely comfortable.

Purchased two shirts in different colors. So far I am very pleased with the shirt.

Only thing I would change is the size I purchased. The clerk insisted that these ran big and I would need a large in one shirt, but a medium in this one. Wrong..... I needed a large in both and now they won't exchange it. And I have my receipt.

Let me start by saying I love this shirt but found a problem with the fabric. I wore this shirt less than six times and cared for it according to the label. I noticed after my last wash that the shirt has begun to shed. I have two of these shirts and the one that is shedding was worn much less than the other. I do not have the same problem with the other shirt. I explained this to Johnston & Murphy Customer Service and they immediately offered to replace it or give me a store credit for the value of the shirt. I have not had problems with the collar as some of the other reviews had indicated. I would have normally given this shirt a 5 star rating but the quality needs to be improved. I was planning to give it 3 stars but that was before I called Customer Service and received a very respectful apology and offer to replace the shirt. Thank you Johnston & Murphy for your exceptional customer service and standing behind your products.

Not as good as the last style change a few years ago. I like the wider collor on the old model

I bought 4 of these last year. I just bought 2 more. The fabric quality this year is not the same: thinner, cheaper and it shrunk smaller than the other ones, and I didn't even put it in the dryer.

Shirt quality has gotten very poor. After a few washes always develop a hole by the bottom of the button area. Have thrown out around 8 shirts so far.

Ran a little bit smaller than expected.

Too small and fabric is a little too soft.

Too boxy of a cut

I like the softness and contrast stitching, but I dislike the white color material in the middle button area (makes it look cheap) and I dislike that the length of the button down area is too short, making putting it on and off difficult since I wear glasses.

Great looking shirts and love the feel of the material. However, material has started to pill after just 3 uses.

Beautiful colors The fit is not the best Fits perfect at the shoulders but very loose and baggie at the stomach area Thank you

It ok, just not very form fitting it fits my husband on the shoulders but on the bottom seems like it could be smaller. But If I get him a medium it would be too tight on the shoulders, I think. He has a normal frame like your models he doesn't need all that extra fabric bc there is no belly.

Nice shirt except kinda hot. Wish it was more natural fiber.

Different fit from the performance polos. Still pretty comfortable. Just wish they had a more tailored fit. Pretty soft too.

This shirt started pilling around the neck after one wearing. I have two identical looking shirts from a different source that I have had for 2 years and the fabric doesn't pill. I wouldn't buy another J&M shirt.

Fits too large and baggy

Nit a good fitting shirt look wise. Definitely not worth the money.

its been over 2 weeks and still dont have my shirt

the contrasting white accent at the buttons/collar seems odd

Great look and excellent fabric feel. My only complaint is that after the first wash I can already see wear on the fibers in the collar area, which has me concerned about the longevity of the shirt.

The shirt tore the first time I wore it. Johnston Murphy was happy to exchange it. Thanks

Very comfortable material and fit