Customer Reviews Aetrex Carly

Very nicely made shoe. A little tight on the sides but thats probably because i am wide footed.

Shoes felt great from the first wearing. There’s enough stretch to make them easy off/on but the laces make them snug and not slide on the heel. The arch support feels just right and I look forward to wearing them on vacation. The yellow is perfect for summer.

Very comfortable. Nice cushion in the heel in front of shoes. Would have preferred better arch support but it’s not bad. The knit material allows for Expansion. My big toe was right by the edge but not touching it. Bought them on the aetrex website not Zappos bc. Zappos did not have them in stock at the time. Need a shoe horn too put sneaker on because of the soft. It’s like a shoe sock

I love the style of the Carly and I was able to snag a pair in teal - yay me! The sizing is perfect - I was able to order a "40" which is my Birkenstock size. I think the fit is a tiny bit wider than I expected, but it's a good fit overall and the laces allow adjustment, so no worries on the size. I'm suffering with a bout of plantar fasciitis in one foot and when I put my ailing foot in the shoe, my first reaction was the arch was in the wrong place (too far back), but as I settled into the shoe I realized that I didn't have any heel pain. When I put the shoe on my other foot, the arch position was fine and the shoe was comfortable. It envelopes your foot in softness - no socks necessary. I wore these Carly's in the house for a few hours and my conclusion is that the arch is not in the wrong place at all, but that my foot needs an adjustment. I'm sticking with these. This is my first purchase from Aetrex. I think they're awfully expensive for what they are, but my heel doesn't hurt and right now, that's my bottom line. Cushioned heel with no pain not matter what it costs. I'd give these a try.

Bought these for work, love them, very light and comfortable

This is my second pair of Aetrex Carly. They are incredibly comfortable and supportive. Cute, too! I will be ordering more.

Very comfortable and supportive. I really like that I can easily slip them on but they don’t look like slip ons. I actually now have them in several colors.

Very comfortable. I have plantar fasciitis and the arch support works for me. Also nice looking.

Great shoe - very comfortable, excellent insole - runs small. I usually wear a 9.5 or 40. I ordered a 41 because sometimes your feet get slightly swollen when exercising, but they are too small. Exchanging for a larger size.

Wonderful support and great fit. I now have two pairs of these shoes!

I have only tried on and worn around house. So comfortable. Love them! The color is beautiful and I like the laces.

I usually wear a 9.5-10 and the 9.5 fits perfectly. I would order down if you are in-between sizes. Nice to wear with light socks or none at all.

Super comfortable. I need the arch support and these do the job for me.

Absolutely love these, came back to order more colors. I get so many compliments on the white ones.

this is a great shoe. toe box is roomy and heal is held securely in place. had to try several different shoes before finding this one.

The first aetrex shoe I've purchased, but I don't think it'll be the last. A very comfortable shoe I bought, in an ttempt to follow my doctor's guidance on proper shoe selection for a lingering problem with plantar fasciitis. The shoe does not disappoint. Right out of the box, this shoe envelops the foot in style and a comfortable reassurance that walking will be possible again. I bought the black on white, and I like the stylish consideration of white (gray?) snowlike twinkles and square-plotted lacing, also the interesting slope of the contrasting sole. Above all else, I can walk again, and I think the tender attention these shoes lavish upon my feet will gently nurse that pesky ligament back to health again. I'm a fan!

LOVE this style.

I have high arches and plantar fasciitis. These sneakers are super comfortable for me with my current foot issues. The arch support is excellent! Love these and am planning to get in other colors. These have truly been a life safer for me as far as helping with my foot pain. They are also super cute!!

So happy to find such a comfortable slip-on sneaker! Easy on/easy off, arch support just right for me. I discovered the Aetrex brand when I was still working retail and needed footwear that got me through my shift without aching feet. So happy to see that they are offering a wider range of more appealing styles now.

I normally wear a 9.5w in most shoes. This felt like an 8.5 or 9, regular width or even a little narrower. My toes pushed at the end of the shoe and I was very constricted. Love my Aetrex sandals but this didn't work for me.

Good quality

Loved the comfort of these. True to size

These are real lightweight which is a big plus for me becasue I wanted them for traveling. They fit well but the heel comes up high which doesn't work for my foot. Sigh. Back they go.

These are so pretty and felt like they would be soft except for one thing. The arch support went back to my heel instead of my midfoot just as another reviewer stated. Had to return them

I am returning the show because it runs very large. I am normally a 9 1/2 or 10 in an athletic shoe and with this shoe I bet I would take a 8 1/2. Cute stye.