Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Tully

The fit is true to size. Nice looking shoe. The leather sock is a plus. The shoe is described as calf leather. It’s actually man-made. I can’t spend $150 on plastic shoes.

I'm truly confused as to whether these shoes are leather or not. Inside the shoe says 'all man-made' but the advertising here says they are leather. Well, regardless these are super-cute and I've had people ask if Sam Edelman loafers are Gucci. I'm sending the size 8 back because they seem to fit a little long and a 7.5 should be perfect.

Stylish, well made shoe love the heel and comfortable. Dress it up or with jeans, very versatile. Did get blisters on the outer heels first time wearing so use whatever you can to prevent this!

Super cute. Four, not five, stars for comfort because they are stiff at first, but after a few hours the leather warms up and forms to your feet. I wore them to work where I am on my feet a lot. The first day they started out stiff, but by lunch I was comfortable.

These are very high quality, beautiful lug sole loafers with a hard bottom under the rubber which makes them a bit heavier but they look luxe. I returned them for two reasons: 1. my daughter said that they looked like Little Lad shoes and I couldn’t get past that, 2. they make loud sounds like you’re letting it rip when you walk in them. Little Lad after a hearty bowl of chili was not the fashion statement I was going for. I bet that sound would go away with time as you break them in so don’t let that stop you. In fact, wearing them to a date at a Mexican restaurant might work in your favor. It wasn’t me, it was the shoes! This is a real selling feature when you can’t blame the dog.

This product is plastic not leather

These shoes are very comfortable and stylish! I had to size down, I wear a 7.5 but the shoes wore like flip flops. I size down to a 7 and they fit perfectly! Very happy with my purchase, thank you Zappos!

It was perfect!

Had to size down half size. I’m normally a 9.5 it seems in sam Edelman I’m a 9. I have 2 diff styles-both had to size down 1/2 size. Lug soles are heavy. I don’t mind…but in some comments ppl complain. I mean…it’s a thick sole. Idk what they expect ?

Perfect fit right out of the box. Looks great with classic casual, leggings and tunic blouse and even knee length skirts. They accommodate my high instep. I may need to put some arch supports in as I’m a teacher and on the move all day. I sometimes need a wide but the medium width was perfect, even with the buckle! Doesn’t slip at heal at all. I don’t really know if they are real leather, as advertised, but they are not a really shiny patent leather either. Classy shoes.

These loafers were the perfect update to my classic, contemporary wardrobe. They fit perfectly! I have several styles from Sam Edelman, and have always been more than satisfied. This is a brand you can be loyal to for a fashionable she that’s got the perfect look and comfort to boot!!! If they were available in white in my size, I would have purchased them, too.

They are a little snug for my wide/high instep foot. They are a bit tight across the top of my foot, but I have worn them around my house and they already seem to be breaking in. I love the look of them.

Out of the box, these shoes are fab, I mean really cute! The initial attempt to get them on was a bit of a struggle, almost felt like there were way too small. I normally wear 7 or 7 1/2 but ordered these in 7 1/2. Thankful I did because I would not have been able to get the 7 on at all. After reading the reviews, I decided to try to soften them up and walk around at home. They did loosen up quite a bit, so I decided to keep them. Got lots of compliments too! I really feel like the next time I wear them to the office, they'll be perfect!

This is the second pair of Tully’s- I got the saddle and the black. Saddle is too big and makes farting sounds when I walk and the black feel half size smaller. What the heck is up with that! What a disappointment

The description is incorrect - it said calf leather, but the shoes are definitely man-made and very stiff plastic.

Awesome!!

Super cute shoes. At first wearing they are quite comfortable. The taupe color and patent finish is very pretty and the proportions of the shoe with the lug sole are quite elegant, less clunky than some of the other loafers that I have seen. Looks like shoes that cost $50 - $100 more! I chose these over the Vionic Kelsey loafer.