Customer Reviews Madewell Boardwalk Skinny Strap Sandal

I really wanted to love this sandal. The color and style were perfect and they seemed great quality for the price. However, the straps were just too big. They weren't snug on my feet and I was worried that as soon as the leather stretched a bit my foot would slide off the front of the sandal.

These sandals fit true to size. I normally order an 8.5 and the 8.5 fit me here. The ankle strap has enough holes for someone like me with skinnier ankles. The leather straps weren't too stiff on the first few wears and I think this is a comfortable sandal considering how there's no arch support and it's really flat. I've owned these for 2 months and wear them almost daily and they've held up well and go with casual or dressier outfits. My only complaint is that some of the holes in the ankle strap aren't punched through all the way and buckling them on can be a hassle.

Very strange fit. Floppy on the feet with a tight ankle strap.