Customer Reviews Madewell Carina Boot

These boots are comfortable from first wear!! Love them, wear them with lots of outfits, always get compliments!

The style, fit and size is amazing! I can not say enough about this boot. I love leather and this one did not disappoint. Since the boot doesn't have a zipper, it felt a little tight the first couple of times I put them on, so I used a shoe horn. But because of the leather, they quickly loosened up. This is a beautiful boot and I can't wait to have another color.

I'm normally between an 8 and 8.5 and went with the 8. They fit perfectly. Very comfortable while on but kind of a pain to put on.

I thought for sure I would love these, due to the beautiful toe and heel. But the leather is thin - making me question if they’d hold up to the wear and tear that walking in NYC does to your shoes, especially through the fall and winter. Otherwise, I think the profile of my ankles and lower legs just do better with low rise booties than these more ankle style boots.

Beautiful shoe, leather and quality is great and consistent to Madewell. I am typically an 8 in Madewell boots and these had a little bit more room so I could have sized down but the boot was so Narrow that I felt it would be pinching my toes after 2 hours so sadly had to return. Zappos as usual has great customer service!