Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy Dark Twill Gingham Shirt

Nice alternative to your typical red or blue gingham shirt.

Nice shirt. Great color. Wish it came in a slim fit and was non-iron.

i like it

Great shirt. Color and fabric are very nice. This shirt is more of a traditional fit. I wish it came in a slim fit. Also, it has to be ironed after being laundered, it is a wrinkled mess after a wash and dry.

Great shirt. Feels so comfortable to wear. Wife says its difficult to iron.

I love the look, fit and feel. Four buttons fell off on the first wear and had to be sewn back on. So that's not good

Okay! Color pattern too much like an American flag, so maybe too much of a political statement

Shirt is nice but very expensive

I'm 5'9 160 lbs in pretty good shape. 15 1/2 neck. I exercise almost daily. My sport is swimming. I'm the classic Medium in everything. But even at my size, these shirts are uncomfortably tight under the arms and there isn't enough room at the stomach level. I only have a 33" waist. While standing the shirt probably appears to fit,, but trust me there isn't a silly millimeter of extra room. when I bend or sit to point the shirt pulls and "opens" between buttons. So, you'd better be truly slender. Slim. The shirts are only good for slim guys. If you have any upper body muscle, don't even consider this shirt. If you any "gut" ...even a modest one, this shirt is not for you. Why in a world growing fatter shirts get styled slimmer is inexplicable. Probably fits the average man from Thailand or US models pretty well, but not the rest of us.

A little tight in the arms but Ibwould buy again

J&M were my husband's go to shirts. Thankfully we bought many of them about 3 years ago. "Tailored fit" M was consistently perfect for right off the rack. Some of the patterns we have are still sold in the store, but they are not the same shirt:/ They are way sloppy. Please go back to the Tailored Fit of before.

Very nice material, but runs quite small, especially in the sleeves, compared to Johnston & Murphy regular dress shirts.

Runs small

Did not like the way it looked on me, too busy.

I bought this shirt & the matching plaid shirt in the same color Mint. The shirt has an odd cut, arm holes too small with the bottom of arm hole just under arm pit resulting in fabric too tight across upper chest and forming horizontal folds. The fabric was beautiful especially the plaid. I returned both for a refund. The cut is not the typical American comfortable cut. They were made in Turkey, Could that be a factor?

Quality was not what I expected and all items were returned.

The arm length is very short and the arms are to small from the wrist up to the shoulder. The material is a stretch material and doesn't breathe like a non stretch material where the weave is horizontal and vertical rather than the stretch material that locks closed unless you stretch out the material.

way to small for the size listed. Should make their button shirts in a tall!