Customer Reviews PIKOLINOS Elba W4B-5900

These shoes are very soft and comfortable on the feet, and have a different, fun look. My only disappointment is the color; I ordered the "Brandy," which looks very rich and almost rust colored in the pictures - I would describe the actual color as more of a butternut, or a lighter caramel? I am keeping them anyway, for the overall look and comfort, but almost returned them because the color was not as pictured.

super soft and comfortable. I was worried that many reviewers say Pikolinos run narrow, but these are perfect. I have a really high instep and the design split on the top provides relief from pinching: tightness. I usually wear a 9.5-10 (borderline wide feet) and a 41 worked for me.

Shoes were a bit big and the leather real thin so probably would stretch out quickly

This shoe is a bit narrow in the toe, but the leather is soft, so after wearing them around the house a bit, they are just fine. Love the color and the design is unique.

Loved the shoe, very sleek. I had to unfortunately return them as the leather around the toe is very hard and it hurt

A gorgeous high quality shoe!

Ran a little small but is a nice looking shoe.

Absolutely loved these shoes!! Unique shoe with soft leather and perfect heel height. Since this shoe only comes in a medium width and my foot is between a medium and a wide, I ordered a size 39. My normal shoe size is 8 to 8.5 medium/wide with a narrow heel. Unfortunately these are on the large side and the 39 is too big, so big I would need to do some serious altering to wear it. The next size down is not available. I could have cried!

I LOVE THESE SHOES. They are stylish, chic, comfortable and perfect! Expensive - and worth it.

I usually wear a size 8 and size 38 fit perfectly. The leather is so soft and stretchable, making these shoes extremely comfortable. The style is beautiful - unique and classy.

I like the shoes. They are very comfortable. The leather is not as soft as Pikolinos usually are. And I wish the Leather was shiny. I think that would enhance the shoe.

They are pretty shoes. I think they will be comfortable for walking.

I wish this shoe fit me, but it was 1/2 size too big (my heel kept slipping out). I'm generally an 8 - 8.5, narrow foot with high arches. Unfortunately, they do not make this shoe in my size. The quality was good, the color great, and the heel height perfect for a day at work. Bummer for me.

I really wanted to keep these shoes, but they were just too loose on my normally size 9M foot. The leather was beautiful and I felt no discomfort when I put them on, but unfortunately my feet were flopping out of them.

As always, I keep hoping these fabulous Pikolinos will fit my size 12 foot. They claim a 42 is 11.5-12. It's not. It's 10.5-11. Sigh. I sure wish they made them larger. I need to quit trying this brand. Fabulous shoe, though.

I loved these shoes so much, but here is the thing. Both shoes were marked Size 35, but they clearly are not equally-sized. The leather is so soft and buttery, and I’ve always loved this shoe, so when I saw these in my size, I was elated. The left shoe was a tad roomy, but I could have had used an insert and it might have been okay. The right shoe, however, was very small and way too tight. I wish I had compared them end-to-end before I returned them, just to see if there was a visual difference in the length of the shoe. I suspect that this style is no longer being made, as there are only one or two pairs of this shoe in Size 35 in the entire US. :-( I’ve already returned them, so I cannot upload any pictures.

Just too narrow, and looked, pardon the expression, like something my great grandma wore back in the day. Quality very good. I guess my feet, normal width, are just too wide for Pikolinos shoes. Too bad. I would've ordered a different style.

The design and quality of the shoe is high, but unfortunately it seems larger than other same sized Pikolinos I have worn. It fell off my foot while wearing it, even with an orthotic insole.

I love pikolinos, and have a couple of pairs. But this shoe was a disappointment. They are known for their soft leathers, but this shoe had NO support whatsoever. It just felt floppy. I took about 5 steps in it and they kept falling off. The heel leather is so soft, when it flipped off my heels and I tried to step back into it, the sides caved inward. Liked the style, but not at all happy with this shoe.