Customer Reviews Propet Jack

I have size 14 5E squared off feet and Propet shoes have been my go-to until this last year. Their 5E is definitely at least a size narrower than it used to be - I put up my old shoe against the new, and the sole is definitely narrower. Since they don't make wider sizes than that, they are off the table now for me. My new go-to is Drew's 14 6E, which fits almost perfectly.

After several tries, I finally have a pair of these that fits. I wear an 11.5D in men’s shoes in both Sperry and Keen), 44/45 in Birkenstock, and 45 in Ecco. I do not need a wide width. I had to order a 14EEE and they fit with no extra width. They have good cushioning, but lack arch support. Thanks to Zappos for their excellent customer service! (The first photo is a comparison of the Jack in men’s size 13EEE to my women’s size 13 Champion sneakers. The second shows the 14EEE Jack on my 11.5D feet.)

These are worth the price, they feel so good I don't want to take them off! Excellent shoes that a man can run, climb, swim and fight in, (not girly like flip-flops, slides or huaraches). Have a heel so, not classified as a "strappy sandal". Great buy for manly men who want comfort and toughness that actually performs.

This is my third attempt at getting these shoes in the right size. I wear 11.5 in Keen and Sperry and 13 in women’s shoes. I ordered my regular size (11.5) and ordered them in wide because my feet swell in the summer heat. They were so tight I could barely get them on and they were too short. I reordered a 12 xx-wide, which is the right width, but was still a full size too short. I reordered 13 xx-wide today and I’m hoping they fit because this is exactly what I’m looking for in a shoe - cushioned, lightweight, and versatile.

the shoes were two different sizes

Groovy

I almost always buy Propet shoes now. Look for bargains. Anyone with foot issues will appreciate the shoe's support

Believe the reviews about size. I normally order 11 M/D but had to exchange for 12 M/D to get right fit. Comes in 1/2 sizes but 11 1/2 was still too small, 12 is perfect. When I finally got right size, loved them immediately.

The second pair feel great. Ordered size 8 5E the first time. Too short, so I ordered 8.5 5E and everything is great. The other Propet shoes size 8 5E fit just fine. Zappos are the best when returns are needed and better yet they have replacements in my size. Would recommend the shoes to anyone.

Cool comfortable shoes.

These shoes were not comfortable and I returned them.

Too big and no support

Too big, too wide and no arch support to speak of.

Small, made in China

I normally wear a 10 or 10.5 in 3E to 5E. I could not get my heel into the 105E, so I ordered an 115E. I can't get my foot in that one either. It's definitely NOT a 5E, as other reviewers have mentioned. I'm going to try a 12 5E because I really like the looks of this shew, but yes, something is WAY off on the sizing.

Wow, my normal shoe size is 12. I initially ordered 12M (shamefully, I ignored all the warning reviews) and, of course, they were too small. So, I returned them and ordered a 13. The 13's fit just like the 12's!! I had to double-check the label in the sandal to make sure the right size was in the box! So I am returning these as well. I appears that these sandals are a full TWO SIZES smaller than marked. Aside from the sizing problem, they look great and seem like they would be comfortable in the correct size. Onward to Size 14!! Fingers crossed.

These shoes are close to an inch shorter than other shoes I have in the same size (15). I thought it must be the wrong shoes in the box but the size on the tongue matches the box. Photo shows these shoes (right) compared to similar Timberland in the same size.

returned could not get foot into them. poor design

Painful

I ordered these in 13 Wide and they were way to small. I put them up against the 13 W's I was wearing and they were almost 2 inches shorter. Not even close. I looked on the tongue of the shoe and it said "13 W". I don't know what sizing system they are using but it's way off. I had to send them back.