Customer Reviews AllSaints Donita

Such a beautiful pair of boots, exactly what I wanted - I'm usually 10.5/11 - I ordered 11 WAY TOO SMALL

I wanted to love these boots because they are so stylish, but like others have said, the leather is too stiff and they run small. For the price it's not worth trying to make these work. It also is a shame only whole sizes are offered.

I've never bought a shoe like this before and I LOVE the look of this boot. But GOOD LORD is the heel painful. So painful I could not walk 2 steps in them. They fit perfectly - if I were to go up a size they'd be too big. I got these for an incredible deal so I'm extremely hesitant to return them because they are so beautiful & because they're real leather, I know they'll soften over time. I took them to a shoemaker to see if he could help soften the heel and he advised to just work the heel and wear them for short periods of time until I can wear them normally. I mean, I know I'm crazy to keep them and to invest this energy in them, but that's what I'm gonna do. The other reviewers who mention how painful they are are not lying. So, buyer beware.

I am normally a size 8.5 or 9, and the 10 was still too small. I have never worn a 10 in my life. They are nice, but unfortunate the size is way off.

I wanted to love these boots! I splurged on them considering the price point and they looked so cute online. When I received them I was disappointed in their appearance. They do not look like $350 boots at all. The leather looked plastic and there were exposed strings of glue around the sole of the boot. I wear a size 8 medium in almost all shoes. These were true to size in length but the width seemed a little narrow. The toe box was too small for comfort and the side zipper was digging into my ankle bone. They were returned!

I wear 8.5 or 9 and I ordered a 9 boot. Length is fine but boot is extremely narrow to the point where even normal wear and stretching aren't going to help. Too bad it's a pretty boot

Boot is extremely narrow in the heel and that’s without socks and boot doesn’t have any give, very stiff.

Let me just say that I really tried to love this shoe but it's been a year and a half since I received them and I still can't break them in. They are gorgeous but hands down the most uncomfortable boots I've ever owned. Granted my feet have widened slightly over the last year but leather is supposed to mold to your feet with enough wear so it shouldn't have been much of an issue except for the fact that this leather is so hard it could cut glass and the soles barely bend when you walk. I did everything possible to try to wear them in (stretching them myself, taking them in to get professionally stretched, using leather softener, doing the hairdryer trick, you name it) and nothing has worked to get the leather to budge. No matter what I tried, I always ended up with painful blisters that would take days to heal after wearing them for more than 30 minutes of consistent walking. So unless you have exceptionally narrow feet and are willing to put up with lots of pain for the sake of the flex, save yourself the money and the trouble and get a pair of Docs instead.

I was disappointed to find out that these were a European size 41, when Zappos listed these as a U.S. size 11. The U.S. size 10 on the Zappos website is also a European size 41, and the AllSaints size 41 is closer to a U.S. size 10. The style is cute, but they are way too small.

so uncomfortable