Customer Reviews Birkenstock Tracy

I love this shoe but unfortunately just a tag narrow. Although I normally wear EE width, took a chance being Birkenstock. I need to return.

These are darling and practical. I was surprised to find that they were narrower and had a small toe box. I kept them though and am working to stretch them out (extra socks and hot blow dryer trick) because I like them. I know that in short time they will fit with a little work as they already are giving a little.

So ugly they’re cute. So comfortable I still have them on at 9:30PM. If you like Birkenstock sandals, you will love this shoe. It has the same firmly supportive insole with excellent arch support. So far I’ve worn them comfortably both with tights and with trouser socks. They look funky/cute with dresses and pants.

I have to tell you, this is one of the most beautifully crafted pair of shoes I've ever seen. The leather is buttery soft, the insole is supportive yet soft, like Skechers Go Walk. I'm just sick that I am unable to wear them. The opening over where your toes go in cuts into my instep, and getting a larger size would only make them too long.

I normally wear a wide in other brands. These were a narrow and I went up a size from my Birkenstocks sandals. These only came in narrow but the fit us perfect. Love them.

I have several pairs of Birkenstock shoes. I generally wear a 39. These are more narrow than regular Birks, but are not narrow compared to other women’s shoes. However, I did need a size 40. I originally bought a size 39 but my toe hit the end. I was surprised how lightweight the shoes were. I have Birkenstock Londons and they are very heavy. These are as light as flats made by other companies, but as comfortable as you expect from Birkenstock.

True to size and so comfortable!

Birkenstock’s Tracy Mary Jane is as cute as it is comfortable! Purchased in the Sand Nubuck in the regular width, which is a nice neutral to wear casually or dressed up with or without socks.

These shoes fit perfectly! I followed the advice of other reviewers and did not size up. I am usually between an 8 & 8.5 so I went with the 8. They are perfect!

The style was cute and the fit was just fine. I returned it because the material was cheap and looked cheap. Not what I expected from Birkenstock.

Birkenstock Tracy fits the same as my other Birk styles. The one don, for me, is that the top of the heel rubs if I do not wear socks. Since I live wear it's more hot and humid than not this is a big con. I wish the top of the heel hand some cushion. If there was some cushion at the top of the heel these would be excellent!

The shoes look awesome on and are beautifully made. Unfortunately, my toes felt squished due to the design.

It is a little stiff and hard on the feet. But I've never owned Birkenstock before so I don't know if it is a shoe that needs to be broken in and will get more comfortable with age. The jury's still out.

Narrow was the only option available, and my foot was squeezed, which is not all that surprising, but it seemed small overall. I wish they would have fit, because I like them otherwise.

Super cute but just that little bit too small. Supposed to be regular/wide but I believe these are actually a medium/narrow. I wear a 37 in sandals and 38 in closed toed version but these in a 38 are not comfortable at all.

This was my first purchase of Birkenstock shoes. I' m sorry to say that the insert was very painful for my very flat feet. Fortunately, it is removable, so I put my own insert into the shoes and wore them successfully last night to a concert.

I needed a comfortable dress shoe. i can't do heels and this is my replacement. I think comfort wise they are fairly good, but they do feel a little like a box on my foot. They are not as comfortable as my Birkenstock sandals, but are ok with a dress.

I wanted to love these but found them sole too thin, and my feet too close to the ground! Plus I've got a thinner foot and the upper portion of the shoe was simply too voluminous. Thankfully, Zappos is great about returns!

I love a good Birk and bought these for work. Although they only come in narrow I still found that my standard size worked well. However the strap isn't that great if you have a high arch, not a lot of room to expand. I do wish they had a wider toe box, but thats just my preference. If your foot is wide I would not recommend this style.

LOVED the shoe, was in a narrow size 11(42) looked like my feet a little short, I wear a10 1/2 to 11. I felt the bottom was to thin , needed a little more sole. I wanted to keep them but was afraid so did a return.

Love the look, but I need more height in the toe box & maybe the regular width would help...? Returning.

I love my Zappos soft footbed sandals & thought I’d give these a try to wear with dresses. There wasn’t enough height in the toe area. Returning.

Love my birkenstock sandals, but these didn't fit. Run narrow, which is actually good for me, but also short - I ordered the 41, usually plenty big, but they were too small. The edge also runs across my bunion, which seemed like it was going to be uncomfortable, so I am returning these.