Customer Reviews rag & bone Shiloh Boot

I usually wear a 10. Sometimes a 9.5, 10.5, or 11. The reviews are right. These babies are tight. I cannot say they are true to size particularly in width. Going off a decision based on the reviews, I decided to get a 10 (thinking they will stretch out). When I first put them on, I was like "Wow! Not sure if this will work." I spent a little time wear them. Standing in them just to understand the tightness. They aren't uncomfortable in terms of rubbing or blisters. More circulatory snuggness similar to ski boots. However, being at the forefoot is leather, I think this will stretch out. The part that surprised me (and I'm still ambivalent about) is the soft sock like upper. It is really comfortable but also I am concerned about the wear and tear over time. Finally, I've had another pair of Rag and Bone boots and the soles disintegrated after one day of use. I've never ever had that happen even from cheapo shoes. It was quite a nasty shock. Luckily I bought them from Nordstrom and they have a service where they replace the soles. So, I think I am deciding to keep these despite my concerns because tbh they are so damn cute, and I've been waiting a year or two for the price to drop below $300.

The boots are very cute and comfortable. US size 7 and purchased in EU 37.5 which fits perfectly!

love these boots - high quality and so cute! very comfortable, and they come with white and black laces to swap in / swap out. i sized up to 6 (from my normal 5.5) and the fit is perfect.

Beautiful shoes. I thought the bone white wouldn't be practical, but I had tried them on in front of my husband, who said emphatically, "You *have* to keep those." Glad I did. They're surprisingly versatile to style, heavy but comfortable, and haven't scuffed or stained after several wears.

Size up ..I am a 6.5 and had to get a 7

SIZE UP

I loved these boots for style, color, seemed like they’d be very comfortable, great tread. Problem was I read reviews saying they ran small, so instead of ordering my usual 6.5 I sized up to a 7. Then I wore them out, making them unreturnable, and they were way too large for me. I should have gone with the usual size, so DO NOT size up! They’re not super narrow or anything either so no need to size up for room unless maybe your foot is really wide. Tried an insert, but that just squashes everything! I gave them to a friend, so they went to good use, but I am sad because I loved them. I’m not paying that price twice though!

These boots are great quality and love the style. Sadly the 10 was too small and the 11 too big. Order 1/2 size up.

Runs a 1/2 size big 4 stars due to price ?????