Customer Reviews Magnanni Marco II

These are beautiful shoes. Most dress shoes today trade style for comfort, quality for price, and quality leather for man-made-materials. These are shoes of a bygone era when shoes were handmade, of the finest leather and materials, and it’s shows. I gave them 4 stars on Comfort, only because I don’t want you to think these are cushy and cozy. They are comfortable though and super stylish. Fit is as expected size and width.

I have been a Mezlan customer for probably +15 years and became a Magnanni fan in the last two based on similar styles. Typically I have found that usually the 11 fits me well where in Mezlan I wear a 11.5. Even when I bought this shoe from another store they said 11 would be a better fit. I have only had one Magnanni where 11 or 11.5 didn't fit and I had to go to a 12.

These were great looking shoes and I was excited to get them. Normally, I very comfortable in a size 15; however, these shoes were very narrow for me and altogether too tight fitting. If you’re going with these you might consider going up a size.

I knew it was a risk to order them, but I did it anyway. These are just too narrow for me. I couldn't even get them on my feet. Too bad, they look good.

Ran full size large but great shoe and very pleased with my purchase. Usually wear a 12 and these were great fit size 11.

It fot really well they run big so if ur a size 8, I would go to size 7 they r also a lil wide not too bad. Fit very well and look great. I have both the brown and black. Always get compliments.

I own the original Marco (v. 1 from about 10 years ago?) and it is much more refined. Compared to the previous monk strap shoe, this updated Marco II is bulkier (almost like a boot). This made it look a bit casual, which was not going to work with my suits.

Really beautiful shoe; the color goes well with navy, blue jeans, beige, sharkskin pants. It was at least half size, if not a full size too large.

They sent me the wrong shoes; I choose the ones in the picture, if you see well the picture you’ll notice the cap-toe design in the upper side of the shoe, they sent the one is plain, I had to return them. The other thing is right after I ordered the shoes the price dropped $40 dollars. I was very disappointed.

I received what appeared to me was a returned used pair of shoes that I paid $401.00. There was no Magnanni box or cover or any Magnanni identification. The shoes came in a loose oversized Amazon prime box. They. substituted these shoes from what I had ordered on their website. What has happened to Zappos I don’t understand. I have been ordering shoes from Zappos since it’s origin now I am very Leary.

I AM A PERFECT 11D AND MAGNANNI USUALLY FITS LIKE A GLOVE BUT SOME LASTS FROM OTHER COUNTRY ARE JUST WRONG. THIS SHOE WAS AT LEAST 1/2 TO IFULL SIZE TOO LARGE IN LENGTH AND WIDTH.

It feels excellently and the materials are top of the line . One of the shoes came with some minor scratches and under the shoes sole have some wear ! Other than that I am very please and very happy with the shoes ?