Customer Reviews Naturalizer Everly

I found these shoes to be somewhat wide even in a narrow, especially in the heel. I decided to keep them, though, and just put heel grips in the heels. I’ve been looking for a stylish but comfortable pump and these fit the bill better than others I’ve tried.

Unable to wear, too wide. Liked the color and style, as pictured.

These shoes felt at least a half size too large. I ordered them in a wide width for comfort, but will have to return them because they are just too large.

This shoe is quite attractive EXCEPT it looks/feels like plastic. So disappointed.

They felt wider than a regular seven. The material is very comfortable.

material feels cheep

very nice nude pump - great height for work. But the toe was tight. Also, I felt tht there was some gapping in the arch area. going to keep looking.

Ordered a W but it fit like a M

Pretty shoe, nice color, passable leather, but the vamp hit me right across the bone which made it less than comfortable. Tried the 8 in regular and wide widths and the wide was huge on my regular foot. Also, I was hoping from the description that the footbed was more padded, but it was only about the depth of a double bandaid which isn’t enough for me.

Runs big and wide. Returning

This shoe was too big for me and I did not like the pattern, looked slightly different than the picture shown on the website.

Very nice looking pump. Would have been perfect but, much to my surprise, this shoe was a half size too big. I have another pair of Naturalizers (black pumps with a lower heel) in a size 6 that fit just right. This shoe, when compared to that one, looks a half size larger. Weird!! Anyway, unfortunately I have to return these. Perhaps I 'll try to reorder in a 5.5.

The shoe was stiff and too narrow for my wide foot. I sent them back

The color was beautiful, but buyer beware that there appears not to be consistency in the color. I originally ordered my size 9.5M based on the reviews that said the shoe fit larger. The shoe was way to tight. I ended up ordering a size 10, and they fit fine. Maybe a bit looser than I would’ve liked but my feet were not slipping out of the shoes. The first pair were a deep, rich brown color (true to the picture) whereas the second pair I received were a lighter brown, almost a tan color.