Customer Reviews Naturalizer Everly

Perfect in every way

They were great.

I am a size 8M but for this shoe, I had to return the size 8 and got 8 1/2. It is a perfect fit. The shoe style is classic and comfortable. I love Naturalizer shoes; been wearing them since I’ve been in the workforce going back to 1980s.

I ordered both the Naturalized Everly (shorter heel) and Anna in 8m in black. The leather on both is buttery soft; quite nice. I suspect they’ll stretch but they are just too small. am returning both and upsizing the Everly to an 81/2 and the Anna a 9. I have had to this with Naturalizers before - I currently have a great pair of their heels in 8. I also have a narrow heel and like Naturalizer because they offer the narrow option, but I’m not trying narrow in these.

These are fabulous! The only heels that I can wear all day and dont feel the urge to rip off!! They are stylish too and do not look old and frumpy (no offense Naturalizer) which is what I was worried about. I plan on getting another color asap!

Very comfortable.

Color is spot on for a perfect neutral pump. I find so many that are too pink or too light and these are SPOT ON. I put them on and could wear them to work immediately!

Beautiful, comfortable, and wish I could get more colors! I have trouble wearing heels, bit this shoe and Anna are the most comfy heels I have ever put on my feet!

Beautiful comfortable and classic style. Love em!

Beautiful shoe & very comfortable

Great work heel, low heel, perfect color, matches everything

I absolutely love these shoes! They are super comfortable! Good padding, cute pointy shoe style, and great heel height. I ordered wide and will be ordering more colors!

Comfortable shoe with attractive shape/lines across the foot.

I purchased an 8 wide because of the pointed toe. I normally wear an 8 medium. This makes the heel a little loose, but not so much that I would return them. They are lovely shoes and very comfortable. I’m very happy with them, and I love the color!

Awesome color and fit. As someone who works 10 hours as a physician, they were so comfortable to work in. Great neutral color to work with a variety of outfits. I wish I could get them in multiple colors.

This is the perfect heel for my foot. I ordered my regular size in narrow. The shoe is secure but not tight. An attractive shoe with a comfortable fit.

I have a very thin foot with little arch and this shoe in a N (AA) was fine. May have to put an insole in the toe but I haven’t worn yet so not sure. The leather looks really good. Bought black & nude. Love the pointed toe.

Finally a pair of pumps that are comfortable and fit perfectly! I am a true 9.5 and ordered the 9.5W because my toes always feel squished in regular width pointed toe pumps. These have plenty of room. The heel height is perfect - not too tall but not short enough to look like a kitten heel. I ordered in nude and black and will get a lot of wear out of them working in an office.

Lovely shoe and in wide!