Customer Reviews Naturalizer Everly

I tried on a LOT of black heels looking for something comfortable. The pointed toes on all the models made it difficult for comfort. I finally turned to Naturalizer (which I considered, “old lady shoes”) because I could order a W width. That made all the difference. If you need to order Wide go down a 1/2 size. Oh by the way I am 69, but NOT an old lady.

The color is very faded and uneven as though they've been worn for years despite the perfect condition of the insoles, soles, and taps. It appears the dye has been scuffed or rubbed off significantly in some areas. Very comfortable shoe but all the uneven fading makes them look dingy and raggedy. They're being shipped back.

I bought the shoes to have a low heel to wear at a trade show. It was stylish yet comfortable for standing 8 hours on a concrete floor.

I love this shoe! The brown crocodile print is so elegant. Unfortunately, the 9.5N were HUGE--a half size too long and not so narrow in the heel. I returned them and ordered the 9N, which are perfect--super cute and comfortable. I would go a half size down if you're thinking of buying this shoe.

These are very comfortable for heels (I never wear heels anymore!). True to size—I wear an 8M and that’s what I purchased. My only issue is that the left shoe gaps open near the inner arch/heel which looks odd. I am trying to decide if it bothers me enough to send them back because they really are more comfortable than several other pairs/brands that I’ve tried. First photo I am not bearing any weight on the left foot/shoe. Second photo I am standing up and bearing weight on the left foot/shoe.

These are awesome. As a professional, I love heels, even though I am 5' 10". I went a size down and got these in wide. The color and fit was perfect to wear as a physician in a 10 hour day. I wish I could get in multiple colors!

A great shoe for the price. Leather shoes are getting harder to come by.

I love these shoes! I know it's no longer trendy but I still really like the nude shoes look. Imma be honest: I'm a tall thin girl with big feet and I wanted to embrace that with these shoes because it makes me feel powerful and feminine. I'm not saying these will make your feet look like canoes, but they are pointy and have only a medium heel, so it's a longer look than some other shoes, especially if you choose a color that matches your skin tone. I love it. I feel like a 50s queen. The leather is beautiful and the shoes can be dressy for work or casual with jeans. I have very high arches and the soles are comfortable. I bought a few different sizes and ended up going with my normal size and regular width. They seem to run true to size.

Love the fit and style of this item. However, twice now I have ordered the color Barely Nude but have received Crème Brûlée. First time I thought it was a mistake with order fulfillment but now that it happened the second time I’m assuming the website description is wrong. Regarding the color crème brûlée, it was peachier than I wanted. I am looking for a true nude color.

Love these shoes! Wore them for a wedding and they were mostly comfortable. That is due to problems with old feet, but I'm so glad I could wear a pretty shoe!

It took 3 orders until I got the right size. I would say these shoes run a tad big. I’m usually a 7 in all shoes, but the 7 had a lot of room so I returned for 6.5. The 6.5 fit length wise but we’re snug width wise. So I finally return and got a 6.5 W and they were perfect. I haven’t worn these shoes out, and only around the house, but they seem really comfy. There is a nice cushion footbed so I assume even with longer wear, it will be comfy. I even went ahead and purchased the same shoes but in the taller heel! I would recommend these shoes.

I am 69 and have a bunion so needed to order a wide shoe to accommodate this condition. These pumps were not only stylish but also quite comfortable and fit my foot without slipping off. The heel height was just right without being too high and I actually walked several city blocks in these shoes without distress! I would highly recommend these pumps to anyone needing a comfortable pump.

These shoes fit perfectly! I’m usually a 9 M but with my lady foot bunion I had to go 9W They are comfy and that extra width mattered. I did put a small soft heel pad mostly for comfort. They do not flop off but made them a bit more comfy. Some said go down 1/2 size. I chose not too. I need the room in the toes. I can wear these to dress up or down. Truly a closet staple. I’m 68 but still fashionable !

Seriously so comfy. I don't know how Naturalizer does it, but THANKS! Soft and cushy in heel and toe. Nailed it.

These are classic black pumps. They feel very comfortable initially, but will require a day or two to break them in. They are just what I was looking for. From purchase to front door, took 2 days. No

These are sooo comfortable. The color was lighter then expected but I am keeping because of how comfort they are.