Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy Waterproof XC4® Cahill Moc Lace-Up

I normally buy 10.5 M but found these too tight. The 11M was just right. Nice leather.

Toe box was just a little too small. Leather was very nice. Really wanted to like them. Not for my feet.

Terrific shoe at a great price. Delivery was quick. I'm satified.

Great shoes. There was some breaking in needed for these shoes, after a week they were feeling great. Love the look of these shoes.

my size is nine and a half, so the size is good. however they are a little tight, as i usually go for wide as, i guess for standard size. otherwise i like the style

We really wanted these to work. My husband had to get a size 12 to finally fit (he's usually an 11). But, even after finding it, we realized they are waterproof. Wearing them for a bit around the house and his feet were so hot, he realized these are not the shoes for him. So, beware of both the sizing (run very small) and the fact that they are waterproof.

My husband tried on this (11.5) and also a size 11, and neither fit. He usually wears size 11. Very surprising that both of these sizes felt so snug and were way too small. Finally got a 12 and we're keeping that. Hope that Johnston & Murphy is sill making good quality shoes but their sizing for this style (and others?) is really suspect.

I should have read the reviews before ordering. This shoe was too small even though it's 10.5 like all of my J&M shoes. I have the predecessor to this shoe, it fits perfectly and very comfortable, visually comparing this shoe next to my old version you can clearly see this shoe is made smaller.