Customer Reviews Birkenstock Buckley Shearling - Suede

My first order was the Boston shearling in my normal size 38 and I could barely get my foot in it because it only came in narrow. I returned those and ordered the Buckley in a 39 (it also only comes in narrow) and it fit. Actually the left foot was perfect but the right foot was tight and a little less comfortable. After wearing for a while they are broken in and are comfortable. The footbed is ok but I don't feel the toe bar as strongly as my other Birks. I have a Morton's neuroma and Birks never aggravate it - which is why I have about 10 pairs in all different colors! LOL! I love the new Buckley style and perfect for our mild Arizona winters. Suggestion: more colors and treat them to be water resistant.

Super cute slide on. I have size 39 in my Arizona’s and went with the same. Wish they offered the wider footbed but I am still able to wear the narrow, even though I’m on wider side. I have been wearing socks otherwise I could see the elastic on top being bothersome if like me, you have a high instep. The green seemed darker than in photos but I still love them. Waited months to finally buy these and it was worth it. Great service as usual from Zappos.

Love, love, love these shoes! They feel like cozy slippers and I actually look forward to wearing them. I have been an elementary teacher for 19 years, which means 19 years of standing all day on hard tile floors. My feet, ankles, and knees were starting to hurt to the point that I tried to avoid things that involved much extra walking. These shoes really have been life changing. They are extremely comfortable while I am wearing them, and they have also helped my feet and ankles heal from years of long days in lousy shoes; I just feel better overall. I don’t think I have worn another pair of shoes to work in winter since I bought these. I got the same size as I buy in Big Buckle Gizehs and they fit perfectly. I have the black and tea, and am here for the stone. Never again will I be without a pair of these shoes!

Cute and comfy -My favorite slip on shoes fall through spring. Great arch support for plantar fasciitis. I am 6.5-7 average toe box area with narrow heel /medium width so sized up to 38 since they are narrow but the toe box was perfectly fine with wiggle room, arch support fit perfectly, open heel so narrow fit well for my narrow heel. The shearling keeps my feet warm and provides some cushion for all day comfort. Have these without shearling and wear 37 in those for warm days when I don’t want insulation.

I ordered the tea/natural. It looked lighter in the online photo. I thought it would be a lighter golden brown but these are still great! I have a really average size 6 foot. Medium arch. This fit perfectly. The shearling makes it soft and cozy. No issues with anything scratchy on the sides or inside. I have these without the shearling and they are a little looser which is perfect when it gets warmer. I love these! If the pink goes on sale, I will definitely order another one.

My foot is a 9N and these Buckley Shearlings fit me in the 8-8.5N size. I will tell you that the shoe without the shearling was too wide on my foot. The shearling besides being cozy provides extra padding and helps with the fit for someone that has a narrow foot.

These are fantastic. But with the shearling lining, I had to order one size larger than my regular Birkenstock sandals. I normally wear a Euro 40 but ordered a 41 in these and they are perfect. Comfortable and cozy. Great for Northwest winter!

I normally wear a 7 or 7.5 wide shoe. I had to size down in these. They are comfortable and room for my wide feet!

I love them. They’re very comfortable probably because of the fur lining. It’s not too narrow (I have average feet with medium arch support) and I’m usually a 6.5, went with a size 37. I tried a size up because reviews stated that the toe box was short, or something, but not an issue for me. I don’t have long toes or short ones though, just very average. I’d like to get another one tbh, for outdoor shoes because I’m keeping these ones as indoor slippers ;P

I love these shoes, they are very comfortable and cozy.

If you already like Birkenstocks you will like these! I thought I'd use as slippers indoors but I wear them everywhere. The lining is cozy, it will probably be too warm in summer, and so far has only shed a little bit. These are the only shoes I can wear without my ortho arch supports. Bonus they are CUTE!

Bought these as a winter work shoe and love them bought my usually size and they fit perfectly

These are one of the shoes that immediately after putting them you say “not OMG, but OH. MY. GOD. Yes folks they are THAT comfortable! Oh please, do not hesitate.. just go for it. And the olive green??? To DIE for!

The fit is fabulous! They also look more narrow than I expected. They are very stylish. I am so happy I got these.

Shearling is not gray like the picture, it came in black which the black rubs off on your feet :-(

I like everything about this shoe. It is so comfortable. Love the shearling lining. I have neuropathy in my feet and this shoe just feels so good on my feet.v

I love these, but have to return because they are WAY too narrow.

My new favorite shoe inside and outside.

These shearling lined Birkenstock’s are my new favorite every single day shoes. They are so comfortable, a couple of times I worried I’d left the house in my slippers. In fact, I’ve pretty much quit wearing my slippers in favor of these. They do seem to run a size larger than my normal Birkenstock size, so I suggest buying a full size down.

Love these shoes; this was going to be my third pair. I'm on the petite side with narrow feet and bony ankles, and the Birkenstock Boston--the other closed-toe clog--looks sort of clownish on me. Buckley has a great combination of comfort and cuteness. Just be aware that Zappos's current picture of the Shearling Buckley in Black shows a grey lining, but they actually have a black shearling interior. I've had them in the past and they dyed my feet. Was hoping to avoid that this time around but I guess that means going with a different color.

I saw these last year and thought I would really enjoy wearing them. Yes I had worn Birkenstock’s in the past and loved them but had never gotten close toed shoes in this brand. These are not only cute but very comfy! I got the narrow width as recommended by another customer and they are just perfect!

I wear a half size and first went down a size at the recommendation of a shore store sales clerk, but had to switch it out for the size up instead after getting the first pair. Now that I have the right size, I LOVE these shoes. I want to get more! Great for those of us in the PNW!

I like these more than I thought I would. They're a little slipper-ish but that's fine with me. I bought these in green, the color is not as vibrant as the photo though. They are narrow and if you have a wide foot they probably won't fit too well.

These Birkenstocks are wonderful! They were marked as narrow but they fit me perfectly and I have a small but ordinary foot. I have some toe pain typically with some shoes but the shape of this shoe removes any pressure. The shearling lining is divine. I wear them with light socks in the winter, but I could go sock less as the season changes. I like the casual yet classy look -- the stitching adds something special.