Customer Reviews Columbia Ice Maiden II Slip

Good stylish boot. Had to return to get the next size up.

Received this boot so I can use before/after skiing, walking to the mailbox, etc. I would say that everything about this boot is GREAT, except there's absolutely no consideration to foot support. Not great for longer walking unless you change out the insoles....which I did. On top of getting them on sale, I would definitely recommend and would likely buy again, if available. Went up one size so I can wear a thicker sock on occasion.

A little narrow, couldn't keep them.

I really wanted to like these boots. They were comfy from the minute I put them on, with great treads, & altho I didn't wear them outside, they were toasty enough indoors that I'm sure they'd be fine; they're rated to a below-zero temp I don't usually see. However, the mixed suede/quilted fabric/rubber styling is clunky rather than stylish (at least in black), & I'm not crazy about the light gray faux fur ~ it would probably get dirty fairly quickly. But the dealbreaker for me was something I didn't notice when I ordered them: There's no zipper! Which means it's tough to tuck jeans in smoothly, & hard to make a gator work with snow pants. For some reason (perhaps the missing zipper?) the back also dips down an inch or two lower than the front, which is a great way to get snow down your boot if it's more than 3-4" deep. Depending on where you live, these could be warm, comfy boots. But these didn't pass the functionality test for me, so unfortunately, they're going back.

I'm a size 8.5 but bought a 9. it fits just right

These boots are what I have been looking forward to having for the increment weather

Bought for my wife. She loves them.

My wife loved it. It has comfort and functional. I was s big hit with this purchase.

Excellent warmth on bitter cold days! Sizing does run slightly small, but after reading other reviews, I ordered a half size up, which fit nicely. Some snugg-ness in the toes, but I have wide feet, and after wearing a couple of times, the toes seemed to stretch and conform to my feet.

They are pretty comfortable when you get them on..... Very hard time pulling them on but other than that not bad....

I ordered an 8.5 and they fit perfectly. I haven't worn them yet, but will shortly as the weather in NJ is getting cooler.

I love this boot. It looks stylish and functions wonderfully in bad weather. Nice and warm! My only complaint is that there is no pull on the back of be boot to pull it on. When you have layers like socks and pants being tucked into the boot, it's sometimes hard to slip on.

They were too small so my Mother scored a new pair of boots. She loves them! Lol!

I selected black but the color looks like a dark grren. It says shoes will keep warm your feet. but it doesn't keep my toes warm in cold weather.

Runs small. Order half size larger than you usually wear. This boot is not rated for very cold temperatures. When outside in the cold Minnesota winter temperatures for a long period of time my feet get cold in this boot. It works fine when running errands going in and out of stores and the car. When the bottom of the boot is wet they tend to squeak and make noise on the store floors, which isn't great. I ordered black and it tends to show the white salt on the boot. Other areas may not have salt issues. It could just the Minnesota way of combating the ice and snow. I do have to wipe the boot off periodically to get rid of the white color on the toe area. They are comfortable though. It is a decent boot.

I love how these boots look! I'm so disappointed that I will have to return them. Based on the reviews, I did order a half size larger than what I wear in shoes. (I normally wear a 7 and I ordered a 7.5) The 7.5 were STILL too narrow...and forget about putting two pairs of socks on or thicker socks. The length of a size 8 would be way too long for my feet...so sizing up a full size would not help either. For me, they were very uncomfortable. I guess if you have narrow feet, these would be okay and might be comfortable for you. If you have wider feet, don't even bother.

So disappointed- these are too small, too tight and very hard to get on (and I ordered the correct size).

I could not even get these on. There are no loops or handles to use to pull on.

The sole felt comfortable for walking but it was short in the toe and overall not wide enough for a thick sock. It didn't feel like it would be warm enough to wear in the cold and snow. The height of the boot is shorter than I would like for keeping snow out.

I live in the mountains where it snows. I tried this and my socks and boots were wet right away. The snow never covered my boot on top. It was along the sides and were the stitching on top was yet. I thought it was just me and yet it again it happened. I was really hoping this was the snow boot for me.

I couldn't even get them on even though I ordered up a size based on the other reviews.

These boots have no traction in slushy or icy conditions. Constantly slipping. Also in rain on some surfaces, no traction. My Bearpaws have much better traction than these boots. Very disappointed. After about a week of wear, one boot started leaking.