Customer Reviews Naturalizer Fae Wide Calf

I had ordered the suede version of these boots, but the shaft was too tight, so I decided to try these. The leather is so incredibly soft and the shaft was just right, but the footbed was so incredibly uncomfortable I knew I’d never wear them (it feels like there is something missing between the heel and footbed). Love the leather though!!

The toe box runs a bit narrow for the "wide-width" - also, note, there is not a full length zipper, just a small zipper by the ankle. I found it difficult to get the boots on/off. But they style is gorgeous, and the leather so soft, supple, and high quality!

This is a cute boot. The shaft is REALLY wide. I always buy wide calf boots (over the last ~12 years I've had 3 pairs of naturalizer wide calf boots), but these were too big for me. But I think they could be cute if you were looking for a slouchy boot. That said, there was no support in the foot bed. Just wearing them around my house to try them on was kind of uncomfortable. Definitely not the same level of quality I had in my previous naturalizer boots, so I am returning them.

Great boot. Fit my calf circumference exactly as it claimed to measure. I usually wear a 7 1/2 in a sandal, but always order an 8 in a boot. This is just because of how boots fit, and wearing a sock, etc. I ordered a 9 in this boot and it fit me perfectly! So I would say if you are on the fence on which size to order, size up one size. Everything else about this boot feels lovely. The leather is nice. The style is interesting and classy. And I love how Zappos sends stuff so quickly! Amazing.

I love these boots. I have large calves and these fit I was amazed. There is an elastic gore that helps pull them up, then they stayed in place all day. I got a lot of compliments. They were also so comfy. I worried that the tow would be uncomfortable but it wasn’t.

I love the look of these boots but they definitely run big. BUT I have large calves and have an impossible time trying to find boots that fit and these did! They are great other than the fact they are a little big.

I normally don't fit a regular calf so I order the wide calf but these were far to large for me. I am going to try the regular calf to see if it fits. If you find wide calf boots are normally too small for you then these might be perfect for you.

The foot width was fine but the WC shaft was just too wide. They really gapped are the top even with leggings tucked in. Returned and got the Daelyn boot instead.

The shoe part of this boot fit perfectly, but the rest of the boot was ridiculously wide. I've tried without luck to get "regular" boots to fit over my muscular calves, and when that failed, I tried this boot. But it seriously looks silly. Too wide all the way down the length and at a least a 1.5 inch gap at the top. The search continues...

I wanted to love these but they are going back. I have wide calves and these where huge. Plus, the ankles were way to large. There is a small zipper by the ankle to help get them on/off. They were so big I didn’t need it. I wasn’t impressed with the quality of the suede. All in all not impressed.

These are unwearable boots! Adore the look of these gorgeous boots and even with all the negative reviews I ordered them anyway. Although gorgeous they are ill designed, the heel is higher than indicated, and the calf is waaaay to wide. Unbelievable anyone could wear these boots long enough to walk out of the house!

The boot was ordered to be wide calf but the fit was extremely wide. I returned it for another pair.