Customer Reviews TOMS Mallory

I’m a 7.5 in traditional Toms and a pair of boots but in flats I am a 7. These are SO cute and they’re so cushy and have great support. A lot of times pointed toe shoes are too narrow but these are not. The only bad thing so far is rubbing on one of my heels but I’m assuming that will go a way once they’re worn in a bit.

I love these shoes but the toe box is too low and the heel too wide. I am crying because the styling is PERFECT. Love the look. Love the soles. Exactly what I want. Groan.

Great shoes. Hard to find women’s flats to wear socks with in winter with weatherproof soles that are dressy enough for work. Uncomfortable at first on my wider feet but broke in nicely like old fashioned natural materials.

First, this is a beautiful shoe! I loved the tread and two tone color! I had to return because I wear a size 9 M or 9.5M. I bought size 9.5 and it felt 1/2 size too big. I could have made it work by putting in a shoe pad, but not for this price. Do not pass on this shoe, but I suggest if you are caught between sizes like I am, size .5 smaller.

Loved this shoe but unfortunately the 8.5 was a little long and wide and the 8 was just a tad short. The leather was very nice and the shoe felt comfortable.

Adorable - a feminine take on a classic masculine style. A little uncomfortable/rubbing along the instep, but the size I ordered is too large so that may be the reason. I am between a 7 and 7.5, depends on the brand, and these I definitely need in a 7. Should also say my foot is wider and I struggle with a lot of loafers/flats being too narrow. Took them out of the box and expected them to be way too narrow, but was pleasantly surprised by the comfort. Will be ordering the other size asap!

Ordered Sz 9..too big. Ordered 8.5 and the pointed toe was too narrow and squeezed my toes. Too tight.

Toe box too tight, and heel too loose! I am a medium width, size 10. This shoe fits horribly. Returned!

This is the first pair of Toms I have purchased. Style-wise, the shoe is just what I was looking for. I was expecting a bit of a break-in period, however, the first time I wore them, the leather stretched out so much that the shoes wouldn't stay on my feet. I now have a pretty expensive pair of shoes that I can't walk in. Really disappointing.

I think the size and fit are very true. I love this classic style and had been looking for several weeks for just the right shoe. This is it!

Fantastic beautifully made shoe. Wish they both fit me. Right shoe felt narrow. Out of stock

I absolutely loved these shoes. They are beautiful. Unfortunately they were too wide for my narrow foot and I couldn't make it work even with inserts. I was heartbroken to have to return them.

Very nice and comfortable out of the box. Not too heavy and nice cushy liner. Could probably wear without socks. Expensive look.

These shoes are super cute. The leather is a little tough, but I wore them one day and they were fine. No blisters. I am usually a 9 1/2 these feel true to size. Love the black back.

I wanted to love these. The look is exactly what I’m wanting, but the fit wasn’t great. I’m a size 10-10.5 and usually if I err either way it’s big. So given a 10.5 wasn’t an option I ordered the 11. It’s definitely too big but sadly I am certain the 10 would be too small. Definitely needed the 10.5. I’m so sad to be sending these back.

Terribly uncomfortable, super hard sole, flared up my plantar fasciitis pain. I wanted to love them because they are cute, but couldn’t wear them for more than 2 hours.