Customer Reviews Maidenform Dream Cotton Boyshorts

Not crazy about the material but the fit is ok.

Waist band seems to be a little bother. I have had the boy shorts tag-less and seamless, I guess I missed they were with a band or elastic band.

I miss the earlier versions of the cotton boyshorts that didn't have such a thick, tight waistband. They were so comfy with a thin, light waistband and I miss them!

Thinner/less stretchy than what was purchased in store. The in store maidenform dream tailored boy short is a much better quality than ones purchased online.

I have bought these boy shorts along with a pair of lace waist an a pair of they nylon ones. First I will say the nylon ones ait higher at waist line. But they all have same problem. The seams for the rear lift show through clothes. I thought it was just me feeling them cause I knew where they were. One of my co-workers noticed the rear lift seams and asked me what kind of underwear I was wearing. I was puzzled and asked what she meant by it. She mentioned all the lines on my bottom rear. I was wearing a business casual outfit and I do not even have a big round rear. Then one day my sister made a comment when we were about to go jogging and said how bad it looked. Soo I put on a pair of jeans and she said she could still see them. So now I wear these to bed and under skirts and dresses. I am not even sure if these really need that rear lift seeing how they are already different in the legs and crotch compared to other boyshorts.

Very tight and clingy. I've worn these for years but these seem different. Not as comfortable as the same ones with the lace at the top. Disappointed.

They definitely run small in their sizes,so we have to order one size UP and the colors are ugly.I love the design of these and the way they stay in my body is perfect,no rolling,no hanging,no elastic bands around my left or right thighs..We need them in light pink color,light mint,light lilac,also they can come in lovely patterns like for example: the background can be in light pink,lilac or mint with small roses,or with small flowers with pleasant colors,snowflakes,polka dots IN DIFFERENT and MATCHING COLORS with the background. THE POLKA DOTS MUST BE FAR AND APART FROM EACH OTHER SO NOT TO DAMAGE OUR VISION WHEN WE LOOK AT THEM.***PATTERNS INSPIRED FROM NATURE LIKE CHERRY FLOWERS ,LEMON FLOWERS ECT**** ABSOLUTELY NO FRUITS OR ANYTHING THAT IS EATABLE ON THEM*

Not as good as they used to be. I have had multiple pairs rip in random spots within 2 or 3 wears. It's such a shame because they used to be such a quality company and their stuff was comfortable.

Been buying these for years, loved them, This last June 2022 I bought four pairs. They are made with very poor quality fabric. When I put them on or off my fingers go straight through them, they seem to have some very thin areas that are almost flaws in the mfg. process. Three pairs now all with holes in front and back. These are not cheap to buy, but made very cheaply. Won't buy again.

There is no consistency in sizing. I ordered six pairs of the same size in three colors. Some fit great. Some were so tight they cut off my circulation.

I bought a pair and the seam at the front of the crotch ripped first time wearing them.

The boy shorts are nice and just what I wanted, but the packaging is distressing! Each underwear came individually wrapped in large plastic WITH its own plastic hanger. The earth and I do not need that kind of inconsiderate waste!

The cotton boy shorts are comfortable and no panty lines in jeans or leggings BIG Problem is of the FIVE pairs purchased: ONE pair had pinky fingertip sized hole to one side of lower front seam about 1" above center panel in cloth when received, right out of package. SECOND pair developed a hole in the same spot after being washed (delicate, cold), prior to wear. THIRD pair ripped (and completely tore apart like stripper guy breakaway pants, lol) while removing them after the first time wearing. Pay shipping and hassle to return I didn't bother. These are cheap, I guess you get what you pay for. But 3 out of 5 defective? Not good! That being said, I've purchased these several times over the past few years, and not had this much trouble. Older pairs I have do tend to get a hole in that same vicinity, eventually.

The zigzag stitching was not completely sewn around the lace; therefore, holes came in the panties.

I wear boy shorts to cover my cheeks and to have a smooth appearance. This style is missing the necessary tension at the bottom hem in order to stay put. The seam of the extra wide hem is actually tighter and is 1.5 inches up from the bottom. I felt it right away. They immediately begin to slide up resulting in uncomfortable and unsightly gathers under my clothes. They also have a rather thick and wide elastic waistband. Unfortunately I bought 6 pair of these. The last time I purchased Maidenform's Cotton Boyshort they had a small hem with an elastic seam right at the very bottom and a narrow elastic at the waist. They were the best boyshorts I had ever found. I would've bought more if I had known they would discontinue that design! I give these 2 stars because the workmanship and the fabric is great but the design is not.

Really wanted to love these! I do love how soft they are, but unfortunately, they do not stay in place--they ride up for me.

I really liked the old style elastic. The wide band elastic rolls and is uncomfortable.

I first bought these almost ten years ago and found that they were consistently too small. Recently I was looking for a different style of Maidenform boyshort that appears to be discontinued so I tried these again instead, hoping that they'd listened to customer feedback at some point in the last decade. Despite sizing up one, they still cut off the circulation to my legs. And the fabric is far thinner than it used to be, one pair got a hole on the front crotch seam only an hour after I put them on. Not worth purchasing for quality or comfort.

No longer 100% cotton. 98% now with 2%spandex. Smaller fit. Really disappointed. I used to love these.

The leg part has no give at all- leaves terrible lines on my leg

I love these bur they already have hole after wearing twice???

Sizing runs too large. Totally different fit than the microfiber boy shorts.

I have ordered these for many years quality has changed. I already have several falling apart. So disappointed.

These boyshorts used to be so incredibly comfortable. That was when the stamp inside were white not the current black. I wish you would go back to the previous manufacturers. The fabric was soft and stretchy. The waistband and leg bands didn't used to cut into my skin. They're also incorrectly sized for the last year. It's sad to see this happen to what used to be the best boyshorts available.

I wanted cotton briefs. These are very comfortable but after 6 months they are coming apart at the seams. 6 out of 12 pairs are now in the garbage. I do not recommend due to poor quality craftsmanship.