Customer Reviews J.Crew Pointy Toe Flat in Haircalf

Felt a full size too small. Normally would go for a 9.5, maybe 10 but had to go all the way up to an 11.

These shoes are very long and narrow. I am a size 5.5 and so that’s what I ordered, but the shoes were as long as at least size 6 shoes and incredibly narrow. It’s such a shame but I had to return them. I really love the style!

Surprisingly comfortable! Very stylish! I get a lot of compliments on these shoes. LOVE them!

Really love this cute and comfortable shoe. Fits perfectly without any breaking in.

Usually I'm 5.5 in flats and slip-ons and 6 in sneakers and boots. My last pair of j crew was a pair of boots in 6. Went with 5.5 fit perfectly. Very stylish and comfortable

I love these! In comparison, I also purchased the Frye Sienna Ballet flats for work. Saw these J.Crew flats at an outlet, however they didn’t have my size. I usually wear a 7 in heels, 7.5/8 in sneakers. These flats in a 7.5 worked out wonderfully, without squishing my toes or having my heels lift up and out in the back (like the Sienna’s). They are comfortable and classic in style, very versatile. After wearing them throughout the day, there was no notice of discomfort, which you know usually the dogs are barking!

Super cute but alas runs a half size too big. Excellent quality.

A good basic flat. I had to order a 1/2 size larger than I normally do.

Very nice shoe, but I'd go half a size up if possible!

Really liked the shoe. Unfortunately the left shoe gapped on one side so I returned it.

Super wide and crinkle on sides with every step. Disappointed. They will be going back.

Beautiful shoe. Unfortunately, it was too narrow in the toe box for me and I have a narrow foot. I sized up to a 10 from my usual 9.5 in flats and length-wise that worked. I expected a better fit based on the price, they just aren't worth it.