Customer Reviews Rockport Carly Bootie

I'm really happy with these. I have a wide foot and a really high arch (and thus high instep) so I have a really hard time finding boots that fit. These are so comfortable right out of the box!

I have been looking for boots that can be worn right out of the box. I finally found them! This is a very cushy, comfortable bootie. I think they are good with jeans as well as black pants. The heel is just right for someone w/ flat feet. I bought these b/c my Cobb Hill boots needed replacing, and it appears that Rockport and Cobb Hill are the same company now. The only negative is that the top of the boot hits the top of the ankle in front when you walk, but my guess is that is a problem with most booties.

These feel like comfy slippers! I have a skinny foot, but don’t wear a narrow. Toes are fine, heels slip as they always do for me, but I am sure these are fine for most feet. A cushy boot sock will fix that. Interior padding is wonderful. Non-slip soles feel secure. Color (tan) is gorgeous and rich, and cuff detail is nice. Looking for an extremely comfortable and good-looking boot? Give these a try!

I did not actually try these on. When I received the package, the shoes were a disappointment. I bought them full price, thought they were cute, loved the color online and was excited to get them. In person, they look cheap, you can tell they are not actually leather and one good scuff, the outer layer would have flaked right off. The color was also different from the pictures online. Overall, decided it was not worth the $100 for a shoe that wasn't actually leather.

I got these in a size 10 but mistakenly got medium width instead of wide. I thought the options were wide and extra wide, but instead they are regular and wide, so ended up with "regular" width. Why is "regualr" an option? Anyway, my mistake. Other than being too tight around the ball of my feet, they are really comfortable. There is cushioning in the insole. The trim around the top is very stylish. The heel is not too high but still provides a sophisticated look, and is a softer heel so does not jar my back like hard heels do. I flet like I could easily walk all day in them. I will get these when they are available in my size and width.

The bootie is a beautiful medium brown in color. Very expensive looking leather. I ordered a 8 1/2 W. Not quite as wide as I would have liked and a little larger in size than I would have liked; wish I had ordered an 8W! Not enough wrong to reorder another size though! Well worth the money and the best, fastest delivery possible for online orders!

I'm in love with these. The padding on the foot bed is sublime. The little trim at the edge really makes it feel special. It is slightly lose on my ankle, but no more or less compared to how my other boots fit me so I'm happy. This was just the right heel height for a little boost to casual outfits.

Love the texture on the leather around the ankle. Very unique take on a simple classic ankle boot. Nice padding in the inside for added comfort. Loose around the ankle for me (but I have narrow feet and had to get the medium width because they don't come in narrow).

I accidentally wrote review that size 6 shoe was too large for my size 6 foot; I meant to write that I ordered 6.5 because I thought toe box would be too small in size 6 based on images. But in fact, 6.5 was too large and size 6 was perfect! Very, very comfortable and stylish; can wear them all day without discomfort! Love them!

Loved the look of this bootie, but couldn't make the heel stay in place so it was slipping on my foot. Hated to return it but the replacement is perfect!!

The fit and size of the Rockport Carly Bootie was spot on. Unfortunately the top of it clipped my shin when walking which was surprising since the leather is buttery soft. I so wanted them to work but they had to go back.

These booties are beautiful. They are fine quality leather and fit very comfortably right our of the box.

Great shoes, cute and super comfortable from the beginning!!!

I purchased these booties to replace a pair that is well-worn and (consequently) very comfortable. These fit pretty well, but are a little stiff at the front of the ankle. I think they'll become more comfortable once they're worn a few times. I like the styling details that make them look a bit dressy.

The boots were very comfortable with plenty of padding under the foot. Unfortunately, there was too much room around the front of the ankle for me.

Like others said, the heel is too big and slips. =(

Love the boots, but wound up going with a size 7 wide instead of my normal 7.5. I usually have to go with 7.5 for the width of my forefoot, but the 7 wides took care of that. If anything, the 7s are a tad bigger than most 7s, but I like that since it leaves plenty of sock room. The boots are very comfortable.

I liked the boot but it had a different type of support down the length of the shoe that hit me in the wrong place. Returning for that reason.

These boots are very comfortable. The leather is soft and forms around your foot. My feet are extremely wide, and the wide width fit well. Fun fact - the zipper on the outside of the door is purely decorative and non-functional. Only the one inside works, but that's fine. These are nice enough to dress up a bit for work with trousers, but also look cute with jeans.

Just an FYI - the "tan" color is a rather deep brown. Otherwise these are nice shoes, just not the color I wanted/expected.

I am having such a difficult time finding booties this year! I am trying all different brands and sizes and no luck! These are pretty boots, however, the ankle region is very wide and would interfere with pants. And, all over too wide as well. I love you Zappos for letting me try and try and try until I find something I love!

The beautiful black leather is soft and will conform. The heel is low and perfect for those of us who can no longer do high heels. The zippers on the outer side of the boots are for looks only- not functional. A stylish practical bootie- a keeper!

Rockport...you have wowed me! These booties are outrageously comfortable! Support and padding were it counts, I wore them all day 1st without any soreness. They look great with leggings, pants & jeans. I ordered my usual size but chose the wide width to allow for thick winter socks, and I could have gotten away with Medium width. I have a high instep and arch and have issues with these booties. Highly recommend!

I usually wear size 6 but the size 6 in this shoe was too small; the 6.5 was perfect. Very comfortable and can wear all day long.