Customer Reviews Circus NY by Sam Edelman Sarah

These shoes broke after wearing them for 10 minutes. I wore them to Coachella and literally had to buy new shoes at the festival because they snapped off my feet! At first, I tried to salvage them by sticking them back with bandaids because it was all I had. But they were ruined instantly after only taking a few steps. They were so cute and comfy feeling for the 10 minutes they were intact. Very upset and disappointed with this purchase.

I bought a pair for myself, and my daughter. We both have loved the shoe. Right out of the box, comfortable!!! My daughter was waiting on the platform for the train in Brooklyn, and a woman asked her about her sandals. I have purchased Edelman shoes before, and they do last. I bought a size 8, and a size 6 for my daughter. Fit was perfect for us. I run between a 7.5 & 8. My left foot is a bit longer than the right.

The shoes arrived , I opened the box, and a horrible smell like intense cigarette odor was overwhelming, could be the glue, synthetic material,? won’t even try them on, back there going, too bad I really like them,

Very comfortable shoes. I normally wear an 8 but they were too big so I ordered the 7.5 and they are perfect.

These are darling and fit perfectly. I normally wear between 8 1/2 - 9 so I ordered a 9. Love them!

Great every day summer sandal! Extremely comfortable, perfect fit.

Love this sandal. I have a terrible foot problem (big toe arthritis and failed implant surgery) and these shoes have held up for a night n NYC. If the footbed isn't leather it is doing a great imitation of it -- I wish they came in silver green, because these are going to be my dancing shoes at my daughter's wedding.

So, I have a difficult foot to fit. My feet are narrow and boney, BUT I also have bunions and 2 hammer toes on my right foot. I have a high instep and very slim ankles. Finding shoes that fit and are comfortable is nearly impossible. These shoes handle all my issues and are remarkably cute and stylish. I am delighted.

I liked these shoes and they seemed very comfy, but I had to return them because they were too large.

The moment I put on the sandals, they are comfortable and i love the color!!

Love them and so comfortable!

I used to wear very high wedges but I don't want to anymore and these platform sandals totally fit the bill. They have enough of a height and are simple but cute. I bought both the black and brown. Very happy with my purchase and I would say true to size.

Fits very true to size, and like steady, reliable shoes! Love them - especially the saddle color.

I love love love these shoes! They are smart looking, comfortable, and they feel GREAT! So much so I just purchased another pair for when I wear these out!

Comfy right out of the box. I was concerned that they might rub because they're not leather, but they felt good all day. Would recommend.

These shoes look nice on, and they are pretty comfortable, but the heel is too high for a shoe with a tapered heel and without a contoured footbed, in my opinion. I just did not feel quite safe in them.

These are so cute! However, because the back strap is not adjustable, it's a little too long for my foot, making it bend and fold on the inside of my heel and hurting it. The size is spot on. The front strap is not adjustable either, but because this style has a higher wedge in the toe part of the shoe, it's not as crucial to have it be tight there. They are pretty comfortable, other than the little problem at my heel with the too large strap. Also, for us older gals, having a velcro strap rather than a buckle would be nice. It's hard to bend over to buckle it with arthritis in your hands. I am so disappointed, because it really is a darling shoe and would be perfect for my dress for my son's upcoming wedding. So, my hunt goes on.

This shoe felt heavy during wear, and the fit is slightly narrow. The footbed isn't padded. It looks less stylish than pictured. I felt like a grandma wearing these and returned them.

Nice show but runs very wide. Have to return.

These shoes are so comfortable! I usually wear an 8, but the 7.5 fit perfectly. Got them in silver to wear to an outdoor wedding where the ground will be uneven in places. Great support and just enough bling to fit the occasion.

Ordered my usual 7.5 M and they fit right out of the box and are very comfortable. Kind of lacking in the style category. Maybe that is just in the saddle color. Give a brighter color a try.

Fit pretty well, but overall looked much cuter in the pictures than when I wore it in person I returned them.

Cute. But made very loud flip flop noise when I walked. Sending back.

I loved the price but these were just ok. They looked a little old ladyish which is why I ended up returning them, but I was on the fence because a simple, all-black platform was something I’ve been looking for. As far as fit goes, they were pretty true to size but I also can’t say they were super comfortable. I’ll keep searching.

Terrible quality!