Customer Reviews Magnanni Bartolo

Loved these, but I returned them for two reasons. 1-I wanted a lighter grey shoe, and 2- I went to the Magnanni website, where I saw styles that I wanted even more, though none were lighter grey ( I went with GREATS). That said, these were beautiful and comfortable shoes. I have two other Magnanni shoes, red sneakers, and monk straps. Both are beautiful, well made, and comfortable. I must add that while I took the other reviewers advice about ordering a size smaller, I won’t do that again. I ordered in my size,12, and the Bartolos were on the verge of too small. I ordered the red pair in size 11, hoping they’d stretch, and while they fit okay, they’re a little too small and I wouldn’t be able to walk in them for long (I left a review for the Bartolos, too). I’ll definitely be buying more Magnanni in the future. They offer beautiful and comfortable shoes in the $400 and under range. Beyond that, you’re getting into the $500+ like Zegna and Ferragamo, etc., which I don’t think I’ll ever be able to rationalize buying.

This shoe looks great and the color is really different. You can dress them up or dress them down. The fit is a little big so buy them a half size down

Heel was too wide for me and didn't have the same heel cup as other Magnanni sneakers. I liked the shoe but couldn't get my heel to stop slipping around and feeling sloppy.

The shoes are perfect and exactly what I was expecting, having worn this brand before. The shoes deserve a 5 star rating; however, the contents of the original box had been dumped into a cardboard box along with wads of tissue paper. The price was full price and the shoes should have been in an original box from Magnanni. I miss the box because I store my shoes in the original boxes. Zappos, you can and should do better.