Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Sally

Like the other reviewer, I wanted to love these but holy cow were they uncomfortable! I have other Sam Edelman heels that I’ve had for years that are super comfortable so I was so excited for these flats. Unfortunately, I returned them so the search is still on for a pair of comfy flats that won’t break the bank.

I am sad because I really wanted to love these shoes. They look beautiful and I really love the black suede. But they are wildly uncomfortable! The shoes are super hard, stiff, and squeaky as they rub against my toes and feet. They would probably get a little bit better after breaking in after awhile, but the bottom line is the inside is just hard and not very comfortable. And for $100 I don’t want to spend weeks with a ton of blisters trying to break these in so they can be kind of wearable. I would expect that for shoes that cost $25, but not 4x as much. Unfortunately these are going back.

I love the soft leather of Sam Edelman shoes. These hurt and are hard on the inside. What a disappointment. They are stiff and not comfortable. Dear Sam we need you to return to your soft comfort in shoes. I will have to return them -so sad.

This is a classic cut flat, which is increasingly hard to find these days. It has the sleek design and pointed toe with a nice, thin sole and heel. The all leather upper is great. It takes a couple wears to break it in and get the lather to match the shape of your foot and get the sole nice and flexible, but once you do, it is perfect! Fit and size was good. It's great Sam Edelman has a wide width to accommodate a normal size adult. Wish other designers would have a wide width.

These are my FAVORITE new shoes. They are almost identical to my Christian Louboutins. The main difference is the CL's run a half a size smaller (I'm a 9 1/2 and took the 9) and the leather is higher quality. That said, the high quality CL leather doesn't hold up. These Sam Edelmans are durable as well as fashionable. I bought the black, beige and snake skin. Perfect shoes that go with so much! Thank you!!!

I was surprised how comfortable these were. I purchased the red and will buy them in black. I’m in my 40s so I need a little support and cushion in my flats. These fit the bill.

Perfect pretty flat

Shoes for great. Love the style and color.

Beautiful flats but had to return as they ran 1 size too long. Width was fine (I ordered a wide).

I'm sorry to all the people who found these shoes uncomfortable. This is my second pair in patent because I love a pointy flat and the patent holds up well for the price point. (You find a good shoe, you buy a second pair and store for when the first pair goes bad.) But, YOU HAVE TO SIZE UP A HALF SIZE. These babies run small. That might be why so many people had problems.

Beautiful style. Usually wear a 10W in Sam Edelman but these were too long. Will send back for a 9W. Also I spent my VIP rewards on this ans wondered why I don’t get them back into my account. Thanks!

I usually wear a 10W in Sam Edelman but these were very long. Perhaps because of the pointed toe? Not sure but I’ve sent them back and Wil try a 9W.

The 9.5 w fit perfect! It fit similar to the 10 regular. The toe box of the 10 regular was a little tight so I went with wide. If going wide- size a half size down. Super cute, didn’t give me blisters. Only gave it a 3 for comfort because I haven’t worn them more than 2 hours yet.

Excellent shoe. color is exactly as the picture.

Shoe fit great and looks terrific. Very comfortable.

I ordered these to try for work along with 4 other different pairs of black flats and non of the ones I ordered felt sufficient enough to wear on my feet for an 8 hour shift. Unfortunately as much as I like ld the look of these as well as the other 4 pairs I ordered in the same shipment, I couldn’t justify the cost because I my shifts are cut due to pandemic for now. Maybe if they are still available in my size when my shifts get back to normal and I get caught up with my bills I may try to re-order because they are very cute for occasions other than work for me.

Super cute.....but the 10.5 feels more like a 9.5.

These are super cute. I ordered a 6 W and have to send them back. They are not wide enough across the toe box and dig into my heel. I could try sizing up but they would probably slip off my heel if I did that. Perfect shoe for a narrow foot!

Initial felt a little tight in the toe box. But after several wears, the leather stretch enough to provide more comfort. They go great with skinny jeans. Just love the look.

I usually wear a 6.5 or 7. The 7's are tight and gave me blisters.

Too small

Didn't love these as much as i liked the Rodney by Sam Edelman.. they went back and i kept the Rodney!

Cute shoe but to large for me. I ordered an 8.5 and am returning for an 8.

I loved the red ones, so I ordered the black ones. They were ridged and felt smaller. Instantly, I could tell they would be painful to walk in.

These were the suede black, but I bought the exact same pair in gold at the same time and this pair were definitely smaller. The gold ones are also not the most comfortable, but they fit. The black ones do not fit at all. And they are soooooooo stiff. I have the Sally style already from Nordstrom and they are super comfy and fit perfectly. Sooooo these are either an old crappy version, or fakes.