Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy Stretch Knit

The one I ordered was too large. Size 40. I returned and requested a size 38 on the paperwork but not sure that was what I was supposed to do. Waiting for size 38 to be shipped to me. Otherwise, we liked the belt. How can I find out if I did the return correctly?

Extremely stretchy! Order a size smaller than normal!

Too thick and heavy for my taste.

stretch way too much, even when I returned it for a smaller size.

You use to have the same belt with a smaller buckle and better design buckle.

stretch belt really stretches. I usually order a 40. I ordered a 38 and it really stretched out. A 36 or even a 34 would be better.

Stretches too much. Need to get at least two sizes smaller than waist.

Terrible, after one year the buckle failed and no longer usable.

Great service, great delivery, easy to buy the product. However, sometimes the belt stretches out a little too much. I should've gotten a size smaller.

I bought this belt in three different colors. All size 36 based upon two I already owned. Each of the new belts were longer by 2, 4, and 6. I would recommend you not buy this belt except in-store where you can try it on.

I bought 3 of these belts (Navy, Khaki, & White). All three 36". While they appear to be wee made each belt was a different size. The Navy was at least 8 inches than the khaki and was returned. I should have returned white, but I had worn it out using a rubber band to hold the tab. DO NOT buy these belts unless you try them on in-store.

Quality is fine but the belt is too long as per size chart listing.

Tip of belt is too thick and is difficult to push through belt loops.

I ordered a 34" belt and received a belt that is stamped 34". but is 2" longer than my other 34's.

I did realize the belts are elastic so provide no traction.

The belt was excellent, what we expected

My waist measures 36" so I thought I would order a size 38" belt. This belt is too big and with the stretch it is much bigger than I expected. Going to keep it anyway and wear it if I ever grow around the waist to my 38 inch jeans I have in my closet.

The belt says its a size 38, but its 51 inches long - way too long - also the weave is too loose - not attractive. Also - the message says to use the enclosed label to return it, but there was no label enclosed.

Stretches too much. I bought a stretch golf belt at the same time which does stretch too much.

Belt itself is nice. However it's at least a size or more too large. Get at least one size down from what you'd normally wear. I only say no to the recommendation as it's too large for my normal belt size

This was a replacement for a belt that my husband loved. The old belt was not stretch. Would like to purchase another belt just like the old one. I'll keep looking.

belt is too stretchy its hard to tighten enough for the belt to do what it is supposed to do, keep your pants up.

While the construction is solid, the belt overall is too thick, bulky and heavy.

I ordered 1 size smaller than usual and it still stretched way out.

Sizing is off.