Customer Reviews Earth Polaris

I'm wearing these right out of the box and they're super comfortable and cute. The only disappointment is the color -- I have the Alpaca Eco Calf, which looks like a darker brown/rust color in the listing, but in reality it's quite a bit lighter. I'm keeping them because that's not a dealbreaker, but be aware if color is a factor in your decision to buy.

I bought this shoe a few weeks ago and wore it all day a few times last week. I was very pleased. It is true to size, well-constructed, has great arch support, and did not produce any rubbing. I love the heel -- it is tapered but stable. It offers height but does not sacrifice stability or walkability. The platinum is actually a great neutral that goes with just about everything. The shoe is really cute. I imagine I will reach for these shoes constantly. Very happy with my purchase. I wear an 8.5 medium and the fit was excellent.

After a weekend trip where I brought no other shoes, and these were new, I am completely comfortable and happy with my new Earth Polaris shoes. I got lots of compliments, including that they were straight out of the ‘20s, and very stylish.

Cute and comfortable right out of the box, even without socks. I bought the Platinum Pearlized. I love the 20s vibe they give off and will be cute with dresses when I need to wear shoes with a covered toe.

After wearing these a handful of times, they still don't feel broken in and yet the seams are already coming apart. I'm very disappointed in this shoe. I really thought they'd last longer seeing as how I rarely wear them. I never really liked the way they looked and should have returned them immediately.

I love these shoes. They're so comfortable and look really cute on. Of all the comfort focuses shoes I tried these are the absolute best and don't leave me feeling like a granny. I went on to buy 3 other pairs of Earth brand.

Size is true. Ordered a size up to accomodate my custom orthodics. I have received lots of comments. Trendy and classic all at the same time. Wear with ankle-length slacks as well as dresses.

FINALLY!! A shoe I put my foot into and went straight to work! Comfortable, great arch support! I have very problem feet and these are wonderful! THANK YOU!!

I LOVE these! I bought the brown and might just order the black too! I ordered a 9.5 M and the length was perfect but I could tell the front was going to hurt my bunions. I ordered the 10 and they feel good up front. I had to put a heel cushion in the back because my heels slip a little. There was a little heel slip in the 9.5 too. Because of the T-strap a slight heel slip isn't a big deal. I used to love the Dansko Mary Jane called Harlow. I have hung onto them for years(terrible looking at this point!) not finding anything like them. The Earth shoes are way cuter and even more comfy.

Super cute and super comfortable. I was skeptical at first but once I wore them around they felt great. This shoe has a lot of arch support and looks great with slacks and dresses.

Needed a comfortable black shoe for skirts and pants. Wasn’t sure if I was going to like them but when I received them and put them on my feet they were actually very stylish and cute. Not disappointed at all. Earth shoes are the best.

Great shoe, perfectly comfortable right out of the box. Needed a dress shoe for office, and this fit the bill.

Very cute and comfortable.

The shoe is very nicely made and for the price, a very good shoe. The arch support is excellent and overall very comfortable to wear, especially considering I have high arches and a super high arch on my left foot, which results in a whole size difference between my feet. Consequently, I always have to fit the larger foot and was pleasantly surprised that the smaller foot is well accommodated with a thin OTC insert to keep it from slipping forward too much. Overall, I am happy with this shoe and love getting a bit of height without the discomfort of high heels. The shoes look nice with trousers, dresses, skirts AND tights!

Love these heels. This is my second pair. They are comfortable right out of the box and I can walk in them all day without discomfort.

They fit well, a little wider than B width which works well for me . I like the color, not dark brown, and the fact they are leather.

Just a little too short. Insole not removable; not orthotic friendly

Arch support was not as good as I had hoped, and they were just a little too narrow in the toe area. Gorgeous shoe and I wish it was available in a Wide.

A little bit snug in toe box, but not bad. Heel is chunky. Sole of shoe too some getting used to, but they did not hurt my feet wearing them to work for 8 hours.

We do a lot of walking when we go out. Earth Polaris is perfect, elegant and comfortable. The color, platinum, is indeed metallic and goes well with evening outfits. My only complaint is that there was a drip of glue on the side of the shoe which should have caught by quality control. It is not noticeable andnot enough of a problem to send the shoes back. I am considering buying them in a more sober color for work.

Cute style. Fit okay. The heels felt stable. The pair I received were not finished as well as they could have been, though. The ankle strap is relatively thin, the leather was roughly cut, and the stitching where the pieces of the strap were sew together didn't look good. I could see breaking those straps in no time. Also, the stitching in the insole was irritating on the bottom of my foot. I'm not sure why it was necessary to sew a smaller shape of a foot on top of the insole, but I couldn't ignore the feel of the stitching under the ball of my foot.

Decent looking shoe, but not enough room in the toe and the edge of the heel cut into my ankle

Cute and comfortable

Nice styling. Was hoping it would have the same wonderful cushioned footbed as the Virtue model by Earth Shoes, but it does not. What I liked very much was the fact that it had a buckle strap, not velcro.

Had to send back, to large.