Customer Reviews ECCO ST1 Hybrid Penny Loafer

Great feeling shoe, so good I'm going to get a smaller size and get two pair.

The shoe is excellent quality, I'd give it 5 Stars for quality alone. A note on the sizing: These are my 10th pair of Ecco dress shoes, so I'm a devout customer of their's. Before purchasing, I read a lot of reviews regarding the fit of this shoe to be about a size or so too big. I'm a 44 in every pair of Ecco I own, however based on the other reviews I purchased a 43. They were too tight, so Zappos overnighted me a 44 and all is well.

Real leather so they obviously fit snug out of the box. I just received mine (1 day shipping is tremendous), and they are magnificent out of the box. A larger shoe than expected, but sturdy as ever and feel as if they’ll last a while. Might go for the black ones later if they offer a discount.

Nice looking shoe and replaced foot bed with insert and very comfortable. Oroginal foot bed was fine but I need a little more arch support. Again, very nice looking shoe.

First, ignore the Ecco size chart. I'm a 42, but it says I'm a 43. Second, these are sized large, so get a size smaller. I got a 41 and it fits great. Other than the sizing issue, great shoe.

I knew when I bought these shoes they would feel bigger to most buyers. However, I ordered them anyway and rolled the dice because I really liked the design. When I received them they indeed "felt and were" wider and longer. I am a "perfect 42", have purchased a 42 and own at least 15-20 pairs over time. I was also walking out if them and felt sloppy. I looked at them carefully and saw they were designed longer and the toe box area was pointed. So, I figured out if I put a shoe pad designed for this problem, and placed (stuck) on the tongue. This will keep your foot against the heel and it worked. I had done this before on another pair years ago, and had some of these pads left. So, I recommend try this before you send them back and try a smaller size. I almost did and now I'm not.

Beautiful shoe. Wonderful quality. Way off on sizing...and I have worn lots of Ecco shoes. Too bad.

Look great but one show seemed larger or looser than the other. Felt half size larger

Sizing way off by 1 size too big

Loved the looks of this shoe but it is seriously oversized. Returned it twice after ordering 1 size smaller and still found it at least one size to large. Sperry must have mislabeled a significant number of this model shoe. Zappos, not surprisingly demonstrated its outstanding customer service in processing the returns.

horrible fit, not true to size, heel slipped out with every sock i wore