Customer Reviews Naturalizer Naiya

I have narrow heels and my foot tends to slip out whenever I wear pumps (especially when I wear tights in the winter), so I'm always on the lookout for Mary Janes because the strap holds my foot in. Trouble is, it's really hard to find Mary Jane pumps that don't have chunky heels, look like they're made of cheap leather, or cost $500+. I was skeptical these shoes would work given their price but I was desperate so I ordered a pair. Turns out these shoes are great! They look sexy but are actually comfortable. I don't wear them for my commute (I travel via subway) but they definitely do the job around the office and my feet are not sore by the end of the day. Also, the leather looks nice. I thought my days of wearing 3" heels were over but these babies are definitely tolerable.

Amazingly comfortable and good looking. Even with the narrow heel, easy to walk in. I have a wide forefoot and narrow heel, so I tend to walk out of heels and slide painfully to the front. The strap stops both from being a problem. The shoe is well designed so that the toe can look narrow and pointed, but still comfortably accommodate my wide foot.

Incredibly comfortable shoes. The strap makes them very stable. Also important: I wore them with black tights and the buckle did NOT rub my tights or cause a run! Walked all over the city in these for several days and had no complaints.

Absolutely gorgeous shoe. Super happy with my purchase. On top of being very pretty, and well made, this shoe is surprisingly comfortable. I have narrow feet and tried the medium width; had to return and purchase the narrow width.

I'm very pleased with these! The heel height is perfect (not too high), the cut is attractive, and they feel comfortable. Perfect for a dress or work suit. I have narrow feet, and depending on cut and brand, I can wear anything from 10 to 11. I ordered these in a 10N and they're perfect!

These shoes arrived 20 minutes before I had to depart for a funeral. As I have aged, my feet have changed completely. I was so thrilled to be able to order a 7 Wide shoe and it fit, absolutely perfectly. I wore it within hours of its arrival, and not only did I get compliments, but they were comfortable. Well worth the cost. I wish you carried them in Navy !!

I love these heels. I wish they can make more colors. I would buy them all. So comfortable, so stylish and so sexy. You can wear them with dresses, skirts, dressy pants even jeans. Love them with jeans and edgy leather jacket.

This is a really comfortable shoe. I haven't worn them all day, yet, but they far exceeded my expectations. I am typically a 8.5 narrow in other brands and an 8 narrow in Naturalizer. However, Zappos did not have an 8N so I took a risk on the 8.5N. It fits! Amen! Very stylish, to boot. I had about given up on Naturalizer - either too boring or too fadish for my taste but this is a beautiful, classic shoe.

Perfect heel! Comfortable and classy!

This is a perfect shoe for work, very comfortable all through the day. This is the first time I've tried Naturalizer, and I will definitely keep this brand in mind for work shoes. Especially love the gold touch under the heel. Adds a little vixen element!

i have narrow feet and bought my normal size in narrow and it fit great. the color is just as pictures online, a slightly darker than nude color only because of the suede material but still very light in color.

I normally wear size 6 or 6.5 with medium or wide, and for this shoes, 6W fit perfectly for me. Naturalizer shoe sizes are not very consistent, so I always have to read reviews before I purchase. Height and balance are just right.

This is a great shoe. For a heel of this height it is very comfortable and looks awesome. I am a 7/7.5 a wee bit on the wider side. I got the 7.5 wide due to the point and it is perfect. If you are a true wide foot, I would say this shoe is not for you. Will get a lot of wear out of them.

Did not fit my arch correctly. I have a very high arch. otherwise I would have kept it.

These shoes made me happy to put on. Ordered the W. Heel height is perfect. It’s been a while since I’ve owned a pair of Mary Jane styled heels. The toe is a great round/pointy combo. Feels like I will be able to wear these for quite sometime.

This is a stylish shoe, very classic. I have a wide foot and it fits perfect (purchased a 10 W and that is what I normally get). The heel height is just right: a little uplift but doesn't bother the legs or feet. The smooth black leather looks nice. I have never worn a Mary-Jane style before because they always look clunky to me--not this shoe. It's a great find.

Super stylish and super comfortable! These fit true to size and are so comfortable I am able to wear them for my active 8 hour shift that involves a lot of walking without compromising on style.

Perfect fit - no heel slippage and my foot wasn't sliding forward. My toes felt fine at the end of the day as they weren't getting squished into the pointy toe with every step. Very comfortable and a classic and classy style. I think the style would have been a bit cuter if the strap were lower down toward the toe, but that could come at the expense of the fit/comfort. If you're on the fence, I recommend trying these.

Great fit! Love these. Will be ordering again. I wear them to work in an office setting. So comfortable!

These fit very true to size, I'm a 10.5. Love the strap to stay on my feet. Very comfortable too.

These are extremely comfortable and I love the style! I tend to bring flats when I wear heels out somewhere, but after 10 hours at a wedding/reception I was still going in these shoes. A note on the sizing. I can't speak for the regular width, but the wides ran pretty big. I normally wear an 8-8.5, but ended up needing a 7.5 with these.

Finally, pumps that are a reasonable height, don't cut into my feet and don't show toe cleavage. The only consideration is the leather somewhat matches the price. It's not cheap looking, but not high-end either.

I love these shoes. I have them in two colors and waited very patiently for my size to be in stock to get the black ones. The mary jane strap is perfect. It's a fun additional to a standard pump but them makes them much more comfortable and easy to walk in. You can have a little extra room and not worry about walking out of the shoe. Wish they made them in more colors.

These are so comfy right out of the box! My foot is a little wide so I got the wide in my regular size and they fit wonderfully. I have even danced in them at a party