Customer Reviews SOREL Ella™ Slip-On

I really wanted to keep these because they are so comfortable and cute! But as I walked around my house in them they were just too loose on the sides. I felt that if I were to wear them on the regular they would be all stretched out, sloppy and unable to stay on my foot. The length was perfect so there was no option to get a smaller size.

I tried on a pair at Nordstrom Rack and knew I would need to order 1/2 size larger from my typical size 7. And they fit. Love the color. Nice spring shoes with good support. Curious how leather/suede will wear. Can’t tell yet

They are very comfortable, great foot bed cushioning. A bit wide in the front foot area. Very stylish. While I wish the front foot area wasn’t so wide, I know with wear they would stretch to that width anyway. So decided to keep them, again the comfort in the foot bed is outstanding!

I feel sure the leather will loosen with wear but these are uncomfortably small for me. I plan to try the next half size up. Cute, comfortable, neutral! Foot bed feels great!

I bought the 8 after reading reviews; I’m a 7.5-8. They felt slightly tight across the front on trying them, but soft. I wore them immediately so I couldn’t return them. Now a few wears out, I wish I had the 7.5. That said, they are great, soft, cool-looking, and versatile. I love them! Will consider buying another color but in 7.5.

Like the tan color. No arch support.

I hesitated on these because I have VERY wide feet, and I read a lot of reviews about them running small and narrow. I don't disagree with those reviews, but let me tell you why and how I made these work for me. My true size is probably about an 8.5WW, and I often wear a 9W. I ordered these in a 10 based on reviews, and while the width was doable they were too long and the heel flopped down when I walked. that width was just barely acceptable, so I worried about going smaller. I ordered a 9.5 to split the difference and it has worked out! However, I use my own orthotic insoles instead of the Sorrel insoles. The given insoles are VERY thick - I can't really even get my foot inside the shoe at any size with the Sorrel insole in place. If your feet are narrow and "flat", the insole will probably be nice for you! I used my SOLE brand cork-soled inserts and they work really, really well. The leather on these shoes is soft but strong, and I immediately knew these would take a lot breaking in but would be so wonderful once I put in the time. These go across the foot fairly high up, just past the arch but well before the bottom of the ankle, which is the narrowest part of my foot. this is good, because the seams here mean this is the one spot where there's very little give to the leather! On one of my feet, I needed to stretch this part overnight to make it comfortable enough for that foot to wear enough to start breaking them in. If your feet tend to be puffy or just have a higher profile, these may not work for you at all. It's been a few weeks, and I am wearing these most days although they're still wearing in so I do try to take them off for a while each time so I don't get blisters. These feel like they're going to do good work for me for many years! A waterproof flat is a rare thing, so I'm glad I was able to make these work for me.

I ordered this shoe in a 6 originally (I'm normally a 5.5 in less structured, slip-on shoes like these) but the reviews tended to the narrow and I've had other Sorels before that were - too narrow. The shoe is very comfortable, only slightly narrow, nice and supportive enough for all day wear, very well made, and the carnelian color is great for fall. Unfortunately it fit everywhere except in the heel - too big and I know that with more walking and use it will slip right off. So - I ordered the 5.5 - my toes are right at the end but it fits and I know the soft suede it will stretch but....it rubs the top of my foot when I walk and although I can ignore it for awhile around the house it will be painful for regular use. I'm sorry to send them back.

One shoe fit just a bit tight and the other very tight and I ordered a half size up. I really tries to like these. They’ve got great style and they’re waterproof but that one foot was just too tight and the other gapped a bit so I’m going to reluctantly have to return them.

I loved the way this shoe looked and generally fit. I just couldn’t wear it because of arthritis in fit. It should have felt like a glove but after about an hour of wear in the house, my feet were hurting.

I ordered my Zappos recommended size and my usual size 7. The length and width fit great, but the shoes were too tight across the top of my foot. I took out the insoles and purchased different ones. They now feel great! I love the look of these shoes.

These were comfortable right out of the box. I am between a size 4.5 and 5 and have a very difficult time finding shoes that fit. These were perfect and had enough arch support as well. I loved that they were waterproof too. My only complaint is the color. The only color left in my size was sea salt. (I'd call it salt and pepper.) The back is black and the front is a creamy white. Because of that, the front of the shoe makes my foot look disproportionately too long and wide. It reminded me of clown shoes. Unfortunately, I had to return them.

These shoes were way too narrow for me. I did like the look of them, though.

very tight across arches and had to go up a size.

Like style of this shoe. Leather soft. Seems to have good support, but very snug. I sent back my size and ordered half size larger.

Very short so need to return. Leather is very soft - can see the outline of your toes. Odd.

Ok I had to send these back but I have to say they are cute shoes and I REALLY need a pair of waterproof shoes that aren't hiking boots. Unfortunately, I have a narrow 9.5 foot and have a hard time finding shoes that fit me. the front half fit okay but the sides stuck out and didn't even touch my foot. So if you are a true M these will probably be ok for you. Also the 9.5 felt short but when I touched my foot with the shoe on, it wasn't all the way at the toe. Maybe it was a bit shallow in toe box like some other reviewers said because of the thick insole.