Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Winona

Great bootie. Comfortable and stylish

I ordered size 4.5 as I'm usually a size 4 but the 1/2 size will allow for thick socks. Unfortunately, the box was marked 4.5 but the size on the actual pair of shoes in the box were 5 so it seemed like a mistake. So these are going back. I do love the color and style from what I've seen and even without a zipper, it is easy to get the shoes on and off.

I love everything about these booties. They’re beautiful, a little edgy, and very comfortable. The only reason my overall rating is 4/5 is because I received them with a very strange white hardened substance all over the toes of the shoes. I don’t know what to make of it, but it was clearly overlooked. Thankfully I was able to clean and chip it all off, but this was definitely an unexpected and unpleasant surprise. Zappos has always been great otherwise.

This anthracite color almost looks green in certain light. I did not care for this color. You could not tuck your skinny jeans, etc into these boots. The toe box is too elongated. Too costume for me! Normally, I love Edelman boots, it not this pair. own many pairs, but not this pair.

Unfortunately the boots were too narrow and probably a half size too small. They were also a little hard to get on. I’m bummed to return them because they look really cute.

I wanted to love these boots but they need to be either higher or tighter because they rubbed against my ankles and made them bleed. Sending them back.

Love these boots! So stylish and go with everything. I bought them in white, and they look great now that they are a little broken in. At first they felt stiff and narrow, especially at the toe, but after wearing them a few times, they became super comfy! Would definitely buy again.

The most important thing to know about these boots is just how INCREDIBLE they look. They are bright white, and they are perfect. When I got it in my head that I needed white ankle boots, it felt like I looked up every pair available. These stood out for a few reasons: the heel is a very walkable height and is a very stylish stacked wood; the cowboy-esque design feels a bit more special than a plain boot; and there's no zip (also known as the laziness factor). The other thing you need to know is that sizing for my feet (I need a wider toe box) is insane. First I ordered a 7.5 in regular width. I've owned pointy shoes before, but none that squeezed my toes quite this much. I think I felt my pinky toe going numb. Next, I of course ordered a 7.5 W. I'm not sure how Sam Edelman adjusts for width, but it honestly feels like the shoe just went up a half size. There's plenty of room in the toe box, but suddenly my foot is sliding around and my heel is slipping out. I've ordered a 7W to see if that's going to be my perfect fit, and if not I'll keep the 7.5W and only wear with thicker socks. But rest assured I will be keeping one pair, because these boots. are. amazing. For me, they are the ultimate statement boots. Throw them on with jeans and a t-shirt, BAM—you look like someone who actually glanced in the mirror this morning. Wear them with any dress and you look like an actual stylish person. I'm having trouble fathoming an outfit they don't make 1000% better. Buy these boots!

Love these booties! I bought the white. Look awesome with skinny jeans. They’re very comfortable but if I wear them all day I’ll probably add a heel support for extra comfort. Highly recommend!

These are a classy take on the western boot/bootie style, especially in the spiced mahogany color (a beautiful toned burgundy - subtle red). The heel is the perfect height for trousers, jeans, skirts. The boot is made of a good quality leather and fairly comfortable out of the box. (Definitely wear socks with these.) They are fast becoming one of my favorite pairs of boots to wear this season!

I've been looking for a bootie to replace some older ones. I searched for two years, always resisting the western / cowboy style that has been so popular recently. This year, however, I broke down and went with it. Why the Winona bootie? I decided that if I was going to buy something in that style to get something with pretty stitching and a slightly higher heel. Why Sam Edelman? I wear his loafers and love them. I took the plunge and am delighted that I did. This is a comfortable, well made bootie. I now have it in 5 different colors. Too fun. I get compliments on them all the time. It has become my favorite casual bootie.

The booty fits amazingly good and very comfortable! I received some many compliments! I really want the navy patent leather, but they don't have my size. Please order these boots because you will not be disappointed! Happy customer!!

Cool and comfortable! LOVE.

Beautiful color and comfortable boot. The blueish color of the boot made them look great with jeans and corduroy pants. I love the detail of the boots and how they mold to your feet for comfort.

I just received these and tried them on! I am in love. I love the ivory kenya croco! I feel like they fit true to size, but I don't typically wear socks. If I did, I would maybe get a little larger size so it's not super tight. I recommend spending the money for these!

This bootie is too cute! The blue is very rich looking and looks good with black. The material around the ankle is a little scratchy so make sure to wear a high enough sock with them. Overall I'm very pleased with this purchase

These were the perfect fit! True to size and I can't stop wearing them. They are stylish and go with every outfit. I always get lots of compliments when I wear them.

I wanted to get a summer boot.....I tried this heel height in the Kinsey and the Winona boot I absolutely adored these boots to knock about with for a bit but the arthritis in my big toe said no way.... so I returned them instead of having them sit a lonely life in My closet cos my foot hurt and cramped when I wore them, I already have a closet full of boots like that. I went with the Frye Sacha. These felt pretty true to size. The look was very cool....loved them both!

I bought these in the metallic silver- they are great! I have a very high arch and have trouble putting on boots with no zipper- but these have no zipper and they are the absolute FIRST boots ( and I’m late 50’s) I’ve EVER slipped my foot in with ease. The heal is a good height- no frumpy low heal- high enough to be stylish but still comfy!! I’m buying the red ones now!!

Loved the caramel color of these boots - they go nicely with so many things. I wear them pretty often - I can’t wear a high heel so these fit the bill for me me. They have a pointy toe but don’t make my foot look a full size longer because of it!!

I am loving these black boots. I wore them for the first time to an event which involved considerable walking and standing, and they were ok on the comfort scale. Mind you, I am spoiled by wearing lots of Skechers and ultra comfy shoes most of the time. Wish I could get these in offwhite and red too! Very cute and I like where they hit on the ankle.

Looks like an expensive, good quality boot, however not true to size. Zappos recommended size 7 (which is actually what my other boots are) so I went up to 7.5 to be extra comfy, and they were extremely tight.

The colors in the leather are fun and different. The elastic area around the ankle made it easy to put the booties on, but this feature in turn allowed my feet to slide forward deep into the pointed toe because there is really no arch support to stop this from happening. This caused my toes to pinch and hurt. Not for me.