Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Prina Leather Tall Boot

This boot was very lovely. But even with an additional shoe pad in it, it was too long and too wide. I have returned it. I plan to buy Sam Edelman Penny Leather Riding Boot #8039695 in a smaller size and a shorter length. It appears it has a full length zipper which I also prefer. I spoke to customer service and she was able to find this replacement boot for me. I will buy it on-line after my return clears my credit card.

I am undecided about these boots. the soles seem then... e.g. i can feel the ground through them in an odd way.... I like the rivets.

These boots fit well in the footbed and were comfortable, but the ankle and shin area is loose and baggie while the upper section is snug. It has a weird ballooning look when on. I was disappointed as I loved the look of this boot. I guess I’ll keep looking.

I first ordered a size 10 and I couldn't even pull one up over my calf so I ordered a wide calf - too big. There has to be some middle ground here. I really liked the looks of these too.

I like the color, but the overall style and fit was shabby. If you're going to design a pull-on boot with a zipper just at the ankle, then make them form fitting. These boots should be fitted around the ankle but they're baggy and the shaft above the ankle is loose. Sending these back.

I have thin calves, size 11 foot with high arches and found Eric Micheal to be both a better leather, fit and arch support.

I absolutely loved these boots! I read the reviews that they were narrow in the calf but others said they were fine. They ARE narrow in the calf and in the foot as well and I have a narrow foot. Sadly I have to return them. These are knee height boots which may be the problem as I generally wear mid calf. Read the reviews and know what you are buying.

I purchased the brown boot. I was disappointed when the arrived in how they looked in person. They looked cheaper and more "western" then I had anticipated. I was looking for a boot I could wear daily to work during the winter months, but this boot didn't have the neutral feel I was looking for. I thought the pebbled leather looked a bit cheap as well.

I put my calf size in the search, but I couldn’t even pull these up, vey disappointed, they are so cute :(

This is a lovely stylish boot, I really wish it had been a true wide in the heel and toe box. It’s so hard to find boots like this in a wide sole but narrow or normal calf. Bummer.

I had ordered the wide calf size and the calf size was HUGE! I returned them and today I received the 'regular' calf width. Way to SMALL. Somewhere in between would have been nice. Someone needs to re-work this boot. I had to send the 2nd pair back as well. Now I have to go and look some more. Sigh...

Disappointed. The standard calf is too narrow & the wide calf is too wide for me. This was the third try to find the right fit. The style is gorgeous.

These are partial zip only and very tight. Can barely get them over bare calf. Not possible over skinny jeans. Color is pretty, but quite red. Leather is soft. Style is cute but useless if they don't go on you feet. I have narrow feet and 14 1/2" calves.

Super cute boots but the calf is too tight and they are a struggle to pull up.