Customer Reviews Josef Seibel Sienna 91

Loved this shoe, however it was shipped to me in a box that had no lid, all beat up and the shoes had been worn. Bottom of both shoes were black from walking outside and it even looked like it had chewing gum on the bottom of one! Pretty disappointed in this type of service from Zappos-never had this happen before.

Cute bootie! It’s a tad narrow across the toes but perfect without socks. So, I took them to the shoe repair shop to get stretched. I expect they will be fine now.

My left foot is a 5 1/2 and my right foot a 5. I had surgery on both of my feet to remove neuromas, so I need an average to slightly wider foot bed in shoes. I almost always buy a 5 1/2 to avoid shoes that pinch. I bought these in a 36 (a 5-5 1/2) which is the smallest size available. They aren't sloppy on my feet but they are definitely very roomy and bordering on overly so. I would buy them a half size smaller if I could. They are comfortable and because I have had a heck of a time finding ankle boots that are actually comfortable and stylish I will keep these. These slip-ons are higher on the sides than a loafer and lower than an ankle boot. Nicely constructed and the leather looks like it will handle the rain.

Very cute, great color, looked well made but unfortunately they were too big. I have a narrow heel and they were just too loose so I had to return.

Fit was perfect. I got the 38/7,71/2. I’ve been getting size 8 lately since I can’t stand pinches. I think 7 1/2 - 8 is my true size these days. The 38 had plenty of room. Heels did not slip. I feel secure and solid in them. Have black. Just ordered the brown (Moro). Why reinvent the wheel?

These are super comfy! Easy to slip on yet snug enough to stay put. I love them!

Love these shoes but sadly I will be returning. The soles were dirty indicating wear and the sole edges are inconsistent in color.

nice style, run small and narrow

Absolutely love this shoe purchase. Fit is perfect. So comfortable. Looks great with skinny jeans, skirts casual dresses.

I love the look. These shoes are well made and worth the cost.

I really, really wanted to like these shoes. I wear a size 7 or 7 1/2 depending on the shoe. First I ordered a 38 and they were way too big, so I returned them and got a 37. These fit well, snug but not loose and felt comfortable enough to wear to work. I had to change out of them by noon because there was a little ridge on the inside of one of the shoes that was a blister waiting to happen. I checked both shoes and the ridge was only on one, so I'm guessing it's a flawed shoe. I like the way they look, although they're not that well made for a shoe at this price - stitching on the side of the sole is fake. Back to the drawing board ...

Love this shoe but sizing is a problem. 37 (listed as 6-6.5) feels more like a 7.5. The 37 is way too big for me and the 36 is too small. I wish they did half sizes. If they fit I would buy them in all colors!

Perfect fit and very comfortable. I don’t always find a shoe that I can take out of the box and wear right away, but these were comfortable from the get go. They check every box- style, comfort and price !

I wear a 6 1/2 and ordered the recommended size 37, but the shoe was too large. The style is beautiful and they looked like they were very well made, but the size was off. I would recommend ordering a size smaller than that recommended.

These are cute shoes and comfortable. In other Euro sizing I always take a 41 and this is no exception. I read the reviews. I typically wear a 2A width. These were a lil wide, but I took an insert out of an older pair of shoes and put in these, it worked perfectly. I wear them all the time and get compliments. I got the black, not shiny, go with everything. They are easy to slip on/off. I would buy these again.

I had to return these shoes as much as I loved them because they were defective. One shoe looked as if its leather was distressed and faded and the other did not. Either finish would have been fine for me, but they at least need to match! I already own these shoes in the brown color and have worn them a lot over the past year, prompting me to purchase these in black. I can attest that they are super comfortable and can be dressed up or down. I will order another pair in black!

I've never in my life worn a 7.5/38 but took the website advice and ordered a 38. It is probably true to size, too big for me, it's a cute shoe, but I suspect in a 37 it wouldn't work with decent socks so it isn't for me. In this shoe a 37.5 would be perfect.

The shoe is made very well. However, This shoe is a little to long for me even though I ordered the right size.

Oh, how I wish these fit! They are just too large - you may want to purchase a 1/2 size smaller. Detail, style and comfort are true Josef Seibel and I'm heartbroken to have to send these back.

I wear a 7 1/2 US. Ordered the 38, it is way too loose in the heel and too long in the toe. It might work with heavy socks, but I need it for summer so must return. The shoe itself is a beautiful, well made shoe.

My bunions make it difficult to love shoes from the first moment I put them on. The Josef Seibel shoes were instantly comfortable and casually stylish. They were exactly what I needed to wear with cropped jeans. Instant love!

Awesome shoes! Put them on and off I went. Great looking, too!

I tried to guess what size to order, but got it wrong. I need a size smaller--even with socks. However, the smaller size is out of stock.

I ordered a size 38 even though I usually purchase size 37 because my feet tend to swell in the summer and I will be on my feet a lot at conventions when I wear them. Right out of the box, these are comfortable with trouser socks although feel a little loose. I may buy a slightly heavier weight sock and then switch out if my feet swell and I need a lesser weight sock. I think this is a better idea than returning the 38's for 37. I have a pair of black Seibel booties I have had for years and I still love them.

This is my third pair of this style of shoe. Love them