Customer Reviews Dr. Scholl's Amara - Original Collection

I am very glad I chose to get these boots. I have been looking for a black bootie to wear casually and these fit my needs perfectly. The heal is not too high and they are comfortable. One thing I did notice that can be difficult is finding socks to wear with them. I either wear socks that I would wear with my toms or black socks. My reasoning behind this is the sides of the boots are a little low so if I wear other socks, you can see them. This is no biggie though! All in all, I love them!!

Very good looking and true to size. But could have used a little more cushioning for all day comfort. It is easy in and out. Really beautiful.

So cute! They aren't quite as comfortable as I had hoped, which I think is a factor of the heel. No blisters, just sore feet by the end of the day

Comfy & stylish shoes for fall. Walking around in a city for work has been fine, they're comfortable and haven't given any blisters or anything. I've noticed that just standing in one place, the soles are kind of hard so my feet got tired faster. I also notice that the leather is really soft, and i feel like you will be able to see creases in them after only a few wears. Overall, i would recommend these shoes

Comfy & stylish shoes for fall. Walking around in a city for work has been fine, they're comfortable and haven't given any blisters or anything. I've noticed that just standing in one place, the soles are kind of hard so my feet got tired faster. I also notice that the leather is really soft, and i feel like you will be able to see creases in them after only a few wears. Overall, i would recommend these shoes

Loving these so far! They look great and are pretty comfortable. There is a slight rub on the ankles, but can easily be fixed by wearing taller ankle socks. Would definitely recommend!

Fits slightly narrow in my opinion. Beautiful look though, so I will continue to wear them, just with thinner socks.

Loved the look of these but had to return. Runs small. Very tight and difficult to get on despite being the same size as my other Dr Scholls boots. Once I could finally get them on, they looked great but too much effort and felt Snug. If you buy make sure to size up.

Very nice construction but very narrow toward the front of the boot. Lovely but no longer wanting something so tight across the ball of foot to top end of toes.

Was super excited about investing in a good, comfortable pair of booties and these had failed me. Not comfortable at all and my feet hurt after 2-3 hours of wearing them.

These booties are really cute. I was expecting them to be really comfortable given they are Dr. Scholls however they were very hard and squished my foot when I wore them for longer than an hour. Also had blisters

Super cute - absolutely love the color, shape, but they are the most uncomfortable shoes (heels are so hard). I would have returned them but I needed them for an event where boots were mandatory and I didn't have time to return them/buy another. I ended up buying heel insoles... I did skip the doctor Scholl's brand of insoles because I'm not giving them money for an additional product when their boots are supposed to be comfy. I have received compliments (as I hobble along) LOL

Love the way these boots look but they are really uncomfortable. The leather is stiff and rigid so they don't move and bend with your feet. I have arthritis and need a shoe with more flexibility. I usually love this brand but this boot was a rare miss for me.

These run so small! I would suggest going up a size or two to be able to fit. Also very narrow so forget it if you have wide feet. They're very cute in person though

I was hoping to replace my old Dakota booties this year with Amara. The Dakota was so comfortable; I could wear them all day...great cushion and support. So, when I tried on these Amara booties and found the cushion to be the quality of a super cheap shoe, I was really disappointed. Why did Dr. Sholl's even put their name to this?? I purchased mine from Nordstrom. Are they receiving an inferior product? I can't recommend Dr. S to a friend unless the quality returns.

I've owned these shoes for less then three mo the and they are falling apart! The soles completely wore down and there are chips in the heel! I have had shoes that cost WAY less then this and have lasted so much longer. Such a disappointment. Do not waste your money.