Customer Reviews Dr. Scholl's Madison

This was my second time purchasing these shoes. First time, GREAT. Felt like walking on clouds. This time did not have that same soft, airyness with each step. Almost feels like they reduced the cushioning. Bummed! Doesn't feel like Dr. Scholl's level comfort. Sizing was true though.

I've usually purchased Skechers or Allbirds brand for my comfortable every day slip on sneaker. I decided to try Dr. Scholls, after seeing the Madison sneaker mentioned on a travel blog as their top pick for comfortable shoe. I tried these on and laughed out loud. I felt like Cinderella's step sister trying on the glass slipper! I do not have wide feet, nor have I ever worn wide width shoes, so I ordered a standard width. My foot was so cramped in these narrow shoes it hurt just standing in them. The toe box is especially tight.

Bought the wide because the regular width is usually too narrow but these were too big. But this wasn't an issue until after a few wears. It's a shame, they are nice shoes but just don't fit.

Cute shoes, exactly what I was looking for appearance wise but really disappointed in the fit. They're the right size, any bigger and I'd be walking out of them, but the sole is not very comfortable and has little support or cushion and the backs rub against my heels. Will be returning.

runs way too small i ordered a wide and they weren't wide at all.. didn't fit my foot which takes a usual 9/9.5 wide in shoes. nice material but had to return

Added shiny plastic back that rubs and cut open heel. Original version I bought a couple years ago was so much better.

I've ordered this before and really liked it, so I reordered- but this pair fits differently. It is stiffer and has not yet started to flex to fit my foot like the previous pairs have. Hoping it does if I keep wearing it, I'm not sure if the materials were changed or something but a bit disappointed that it's not as comfortable as last time.

I purchased the Black Lizard style about a year ago, and I have finally given up trying to break these shoes in. This style has an awful patent leather-like heel that causes painful blisters after wearing them for about 30 minutes. I have them in Bone and they are my go to, so I was determined to make my black pair work. Sadly, after a year of walking to classes and around town, I don't think I will ever be able to break them in. I don't even want to donate them because the blisters are still so bad!! If I were you, I would make sure to buy the Madison styles that do not have this patent leather-like heel.

I purchased the Black Lizard style about a year ago, and I have finally given up trying to break these shoes in. This style has an awful patent leather-like heel that causes painful blisters after wearing them for about 30 minutes. I have them in Bone and they are my go to, so I was determined to make my black pair work. Sadly, after a year of walking to classes and around town, I don't think I will ever be able to break them in. I don't even want to donate them because the blisters are still so bad!! If I were you, I would make sure to buy the Madison styles that do not have this patent leather-like heel.