Customer Reviews TOMS Shaye

Liked this shoe very much but have not worn a higher heel in decades. It was too high for me. Otherwise, the style and fit were super.

Love these! The cutest Toms out there!

Fit great and comfortable from the minute I put on

Super comfortable & cute!

These are as comfortable as they are stylish! I want all the colors! I hope they make them in a leather rather than a suede too so I can wear them better in the rainy season.

Love this shoe! It’s cute and comfortable. I got the taupe and it’s a light grayish taupe color. Now I want the blush too!

These shoes are beautiful and well made. They also fit like a glove on my hard to fit foot. Sadly, I'm returning this pair of Desert Taupe Suede shoes not because of any fit issues, but because the color is lighter than it appeared in the picture on Zappos. I was hoping for a darker shade. I already have enough light colored shoes and black shoes so no need for another. I only wish that Tom's had more styles and color choices. Otherwise, a beautiful shoe!

Super comfortable! These are my new go to shoes to either dress up or down. Only slight downside is that they can stain easily.

Very cute shoe. I'm sorry it didn't work for me. It was roomy in the heel, and a little snug in the toe. I think the toe would have stretched, but the heel may have slipped too much if I had kept the shoe. Had to send them back.

So comfortable! Wish the style was a little more sleek.

The size was true to size I wear an 8.5 and I ordered an 8.5. Every time I walked though I felt as if my heel was coming out of the shoe so for me the fit was off. The quality of the leather was really nice.

I'm between 7.5 and 8. 8 worked for me in this shoe and the width was adequate for my wide feet. However, the shoe looks like it's confused whether it's a loafer or a boot. The heel is nice, but the front is shapeless - that the structured TOMS look is definitely missed. My bunions started to hurt in the shoe after putting them on - not sure why since it's a very soft shoe.

I found these to be really comfortable right out of the box. They’re perfect booties for California where we don’t have a real winter. I really like the heel, it adds a little height while still being comfortable for wearing and walking around for a long time. My only issue is with the color, I ordered the taupe and as other reviews have stated it’s much lighter than the pictures show, this is really more of a light gray than a taupe color. A great shoe otherwise, I’m considering ordering another color.

Cute shoe but too tight for toe area.

Very cute booties, just way to tight. I was sad to have to return them.

I loved these shoes but the right felt very loose. I am guessing the left would stretch out as I wore it so I am sending back.

I originally ordered this shoe because it looked like a cross between a shoe and a boot. It was very comfortable, and the heel size was great for me. The more I looked at the shoe in the mirror it looked like a clog. I just didn't really like the overall look so I returned.

I really judge a shoe by how it looks from above and I just didn’t love how rounded the toe was on this shoe. I have large feet so shape is really important to make my feet look properly scaled.

I usually wear a 10, but my foot is a bit narrow, or maybe just shallow. The 9.5 was just a wee bit too small and the 10 a wee bit too big, but I am keeping the 10 and now searching for the perfect no show socks to wear with them. They will be fine with regular socks.

The fit was true to size and the shoes are comfortable, but could use more arch support. The shoes are so stylish. and I can wait to wear them with my jeans.

These were quite comfortable with a very nice, quiet, quality sole. However, the toe shape was a little too unstructured for my personal preference.

As noted by others, the back of the shoe is so low it renders the shoe unwearable. And the glitter was way too much for me.

Cute shoe, but the Dusty Gold Star Suede was not to my liking due to the shiny gold flecks. Kind of comfortable, sort of cute. A little narrow but not tight. I am returning because of the color--just not into sparkly shoes.

The fit was too narrow. My mom loved the style.

These are a bit longer than a typical size 9, so that my foot slides forward when I walk. The medium width feels typical. The color and material are great. I will have to return and try a different size.