Customer Reviews Columbia Twentythird Ave Chelsea WP

I really like the look of these boots and I wanted to wear them as an easy slip on after gym and studio exercise classes as well as with jeans or leggings. They are more narrow through the top than I expected so they don't really slip on so much as pull on but the narrow profile makes them look better - they are slim and not bulky or clunky. Unfortunately, the "slim" design carries through to the sizing and for me they were a little too small to wear with medium weight socks. They fit more like I expect an athletic shoe to fit, not like a boot designed for fall/winter. I spent most of my life as a 7 but am now reaching for 7.5s on a regular basis, but have never needed an 8 or a wide in any shoe. I like the price and the styling enough to return these and give the size 8 a try though! Can't really comment on comfort since I didn't wear them, but Zappos makes you give a rating.

I LOVE this boots. They look so stylish but are waterproof and moderately warm. I have short, wide feet and I went with a size up to accommodate boot socks. It was a great decision. They are not tight on my wide feet, I have a very hard time finding boots that fit well because of how wide my feet are. I've gotten so many compliments on them and no one believes me at first that they are Columbia. I would say there is very little arch support and are a little stiff in the sole but I think that will come in handy once it starts to snow.

These were cute but had no arch support and the heel seemed to slip quite a bit.

This boot seemed to be about a half size small, even with very thin socks. The look and style was exactly what I have been looking for with plenty of room at the ankle for jeans. Unfortunately, the spot where the two materials are joined on the back was already rubbing a blister just walking around our house on carpet. Definitely wouldn't be comfortable for a full day of wear, in my opinion.

I liked these, but they were about 2-3 shorter than the boots I need/were looking for, so I returned them. But I really liked the styling of the different fabrics and details.

Normally I fit in a size 5 in most shoes, even this brand. I returned the 5 because they were too tight. I'm returning the 5.5 because they're huge. These were a dissapointment.

the show was not waterproof!! i loved how it looked. it looks very appropriate for the office. unfortunately, the shoes got completely wet the first time i walked out in the rain. so disappointed!!