Customer Reviews Circus NY by Sam Edelman Charlotte

Pretty shoes. No arch support. I ordered a size too small

I just tried them on and they felt very comfortable. The true test will be wearing them for a day but the initail try on was surprisingly comfortable.

This ballet flat is really cute and for the most part, I am satisfied with it. The shoe is comfortable, the rubber sole is durable, and the material stretches. The only issue I had with it was the heel section. It kind of cut into the skin. I resolved this by getting those attachable heel cushions that you stick on the shoe. Since then, it's been great.

True to size

First time for this brand. Runs a half size larger; however, will keep them. Will try Sam Edelman again but will order a half size smaller.

Comfy and perfect, except the color "silver" is waffling between a bronze and pewter, though I had hoped it would be squarely a dark nickel gray color as appeared on my screen. Sigh, still looking for that color somewhere in a ballet flat! Keeping this, as it is rather neutral if indescribable.

Terrific

I normally wear a 7.5 and occasionally an 8. An 8 seemed appropriate for this shoe. At first try I thought they would be fine, but then found the toe box to be too tight. Wished they would have worked as they are a lovely style of ballet flat.

After ordering and needing to return numerous pairs of black flats from different vendors, I didn't hold out too much hope for this, one of the most reasonably priced shoes I've ordered so far. These were great. Simple, comfortable enough, and without the long pointy toes that made my feet look huge and witchy. These are comfortable except for a slight bit of pressure on the top of one foot over sort of a dancers midfoot "bunion," for lack of a better description. I am sure being leather they will stretch enough before long. There is nice padding on the bottom of the shoe, it's a soft and comfortable shoe. Only thing that might help others - the elastic bow is purely decorative and does nothing to tighten up the fit.

These are a great quality ballet flat. They are not as comfortable as my leather Felicia flats, but for the price, they are a great second pair for me. I have also found them useful for wearing to the pool for swim meets or on rainy summer days since they stand up to the splashing better than the leather.

Felt tad too snug even though that’s my usual size

Cute shoe. I have a narrow foot. Had to buy a half size smaller than usual. Still too wide, but will keep them. I added a heel grip which helps, but the shoe still gaps a bit on the sides.

I was looking for flats that I could wear with winter socks, so I went up a size. Nice!

Fit and size were good. The leather upper part of the shoe molded to my foot and felt very comfortable. After wearing the shoes around my carpeted living room I became aware that the man made extra cushioning in the interior of the shoe was making my feet feel very warm, almost hot. This would have been a disaster walking outside on a warm summer day. I reluctantly returned them.

i loved the feel of the shoes but the leather looked cheap. for $60 i suppose i should have expected it. sadly, returning.

Wide fit. Little support

i usually wear a 9 but this 9.5 is tight.

I have had this style shoe from Sam Edelman for several years and like them for casual wear. This edition is way short. Did they run out of leather? I tried the pair on twice and tried on the pair I am replacing. Totally different lengths. I hope the next size up fits well, because this is one of the most versatile shoes I own.

Fit is fine. Was disappointed in the material. I’m not sure what it is but after one wear, there are wrinkles on the top of the shoe which makes them appear cheap. Too late to return them.

I am a size 10 and probably somewhere between a medium width and wide width. These shoes fit great in the toe area, but my heel was not staying in the shoe - you know when you envision clinching your toes so that your shoe stays on? Yeah - that. I would not get a 1/2 size smaller as that would be too much, and I am not into getting heel pads to resolve why my new shoes do not fit. These are going back, which is a shame as I love the style.

Normally wear a size 8, need to go with 7.5 on this.

style was cute but absolutly no support and feels perfectly flat. I am returning.

I ordered these in my normal size, and although they felt comfortable, they were a little too big and my heels would slip out as I walked around the house. I reordered a half size smaller, but they were too tight, so I returned those, too. Also, when I walk, the sides flare out because they're too wide. I am disappointed because they're cute, well made, and I like the cushioned sole. If you can find a size that works for you, I think these would be a great pair of flats.

Maybe in another color it wouldn't look like an orthopaedic nursing shoe. Going back.

Color is much lighter then picture.