Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Bay

I barely got half my foot in this shoe and I already knew it was going back. I wear between an 8.5W and 9.5W and have very high arches and wide feet. The 9.5W in this shoe was super long on me, but the width was too narrow. I was so disappointed! There is no way this could be considered a wide width shoe. It was so narrow that I actually laughed a bit at how far off it was from fitting. Too bad, because it's a really nice style.

This is a really good looking sandal, however, it is completely flat with no arch support or padding. The edge of the leather was stiff and abraded my toes, so although the sandal is really good looking, I could not keep it.

Fit and size were not good

Fit was bad. Top part was so big that I slipped out of them. Had to return them.

The shoe was not white, but off-white. The material looked cheap and was very loose around the arch. I was very disappointed in the fit and the look in person.

These shoes are absolutely adorable and are true to size as far as the length goes. However, due to how wide an 8 M was I had to return. These will work for someone with very wide feet. The regular/medium size is so wide that my foot slipped through the shoe with all of my toes hanging off the front by about an inch.

This sandal is cute but, a little short and REALLY wide! If I didn't know it was new, I would think it had been worn and stretched out. Unfortunately, it doesn't come in Narrow so I am returning.

Unfortunately, my baby toe was in the exact spot of the side opening so I could not wear these shoes. Returned.

Shoes are pretty, but the cutouts cramp your pinky toes.

Didn’t work for me. I tried my usual size and a half size smaller, and they were both so wide that my foot went all the way through so that my toes were on the ground! The smaller size didn’t seem to be any narrower than the larger size. I also have to say that when I stood in them and saw them on my feet (so that my feet were in the right place!), they really were not that nice looking!

I have been wanting these sandals all summer and was so excited to receive them! They did not arrive in a box, but rather a plastic bag only, and one shoe was stretched out so my feet slid ahead too much in them. These are sadly going back. First disappointment I have had with Zappos :(

I ordered my usual 7 in a wide. I have a wide foot and these were way too wide for me. I returned for a 7 in regular width.

The base of the shoe perfectly fit my size 8, average width foot. However the upper design cut into my smallest two toes with every step. The top is also very high, and the shoe did not fit securely. I think it will just depend on how long your toes are as to whether or not this design can be worn comfortably. in other words your won't know until you try it on.

These are not for people with a normal foot width. They are VERY narrow.

I usually pay more heed to reviews but liked the look of this sandal and purchased it despite some dicey reviews about how the show fit. It felt fine when I tried it on and I even walked around the house to be sure it was ok. However, first time I wore it - just to church - I found it very difficult to walk in and keep on my foot. Very awkward feeling. I have a medium width foot and wear a 9.5. No weird fit issues. It is just an awkward fitting shoe - would not recommend. I have other Sam Edelman shoes I like and wear with no issue.

I was looking for a cute slide, and this was marked "wide". However, I could hardly get my foot into it. The inside was scratchy. Definitely a "no" for me.

The plastic or rubber link between the two pieces (not sure what it’s made of) at the top where the two pieces of the sandals join was split on both shoes.