Customer Reviews Cole Haan Vesta Pump (65mm)

Really pretty shoe but was too big (normally a 7.5).

Loved the shoe, but it cut across the top of where my big toe at the widest point of my foot. A wide might be perfect, but out of stock.

These shoes were gorgeous, the color in the cordovan was rich and beautiful, but they were just too pointy for me and made my foot look enormously long. For a pointy toed shoe, they were very comfortable.

Attractive classic style and an unusual color which I liked. However, the shoe felt wide in the heel area and tight in the toe area. My foot would have never felt comfortable walking in these shoes. Returning.

Liked Juliana style better so I returned these.

Too tight and small coverage over toes

These shoes are beautiful but unfortunately the other reviews were correct. The toe box is too tight, the heel slips off - just not a good fit for a somewhat pricey pair of shoes. Sadly had to return!

I like them, but the tire bed is too narrow for my foot

The toe area was tight but the heel felt loose and I coudn't have walked comforatbly in these shoes.. The style is beautifully classic and I liked the unusual color - just not a fit for my feet. Returning

Too small. All of my shoes are 8.5, and because of reviews I got an 8.5C. These even felt narrow.

Nice , plain pump.

Review on the black pump, size 8: this arrived scratched right out of the box. The leather has a beautiful glossy finish, but has a texture more like clay than any other pump I've seen. No wonder it scratches so easily! Other than that, the pump is lovely and high quality. The outsole is completely stiff, except that some flexibility is built into the ball of the shoe so that your foot can bend as you move. I also love the pointy toe--just long enough to look fabulously dressy, but just wide enough to leave plenty of room for your toes.

I've worn this style from Cole Haan for years in the 7.5 but they must have changed their cut because the 7.5 is now too big and the 7 is too small even for stretching. I ordered both sizes and both had to be returned. Sure I could take up the room in the 7.5 with a heal and ball of foot pad, but as the shoes stretch naturally with wear they will end up being too big. Such a shame because these were my favorite pumps... perfect height, comfortable, classy, quality leather and construction.