Customer Reviews Florsheim Postino Plain Toe Oxford

Like the look. Stiff shoe that will take a while to break-in.. maybe go a half size bigger to compensate.

Good looking but I had to send them back. The inserts are not removable. I have to use custom inserts

Much darker IRL than in the picture - you had to hold it up in bright light to see any hint of blue. Returned, sadly.

They are longer and narrower than expected. My size 12s make them look a bit like skis, but a nice looking shoe. They are absolutely painful to put on without a tool, but are very comfortable once you have them on.

I bought this shoe with high anticipation. The color that I selected was Brandy. The picture on the website and the shoe that I received appear to be different colors. What I received, I already have in that color. I think this shoe needs to be photographed again so as not to confuse the customer. Unfortunately I will be returning these.

Ordered a size 10D and it was too large, so exchanged it for a size 9.5 D and one shoe was large and the other was too tight. Inconsistent sizing at manufacturer.

This shoe looks nice enough, but it was definitely a major mistake buying it for my particular feet. I have extreme soreness on my heel from the shoe. And, unless I put additional insoles into the shoe to lift my foot up, the sides of the shoe cut into my interior ankle bone when I walk.

This is a good-looking shoe. I bought it because I love the style and it's just the right amount of shine. However, after wearing the pair for just one day, the cheapness of the construction is extremely apparent. The toe cap section is completely mashed and warped from just normal walking. There are strange creases in odd places all over the shoe, making it look extremely cheap and flimsy. Wish I could get my money back and spend it on something better made.

Absolutely beautiful shoe! Too bad I couldn't keep it! The shoes were EASILY two sizes larger than marked, (on the box and on the shoes). Sent them back, and they don't have them 2 sizes smaller. Too bad Florsheim's sizing is so off, I really wanted to keep these shoes.

Look cheap in person

I ordered a pair of shoes and got the wrong size in the box! I needed the shoes urgently for an event and lost 2 weeks

Correct size and width but the toe area is about 1 1/2 inches beyond the toes. The rest of the shoe fits, but it's stupid to have all that extra unused length. Plus, could see a crease forming after time in that area. Wish Florsheim never quit making a boot they had for years. The current boots are not like the previous model. Tried shoes, too bad they didn't work.

The shoes didn't look like the pictures. The toes were so small they didn't fit.

Does not fit true to size. I wear a size 13 and couldn't even walk in them with it digging into my heal. I returned immediately

Did not like the style of the shoe.

Ordered this shoe in a size 11 3E, but it was not a true 3E, it was more of a medium

Not what I expected not even close had to return it Inadvertently tapped on 1 Star And can't remove it Save your money

I am done with Florsheim after 40 years. Quality has declined. Shoes don'f Fit properly. They Squeak. They fall apart. Sad to see the relationship end.

Order a 1/2 size down

On line looks totally different