Customer Reviews J. Renee Mayetta

This is a stylish shoe in a wide width. It actually fit comfortably! Would recommend for anyone with a wide width foot. I am a 8 1/2 shoe size. I did purchase a 9. The wider heel made it easy to walk in. I was standing and walking in these shoes and it took almost 4 hours before I noticed my feet were starting to hurt. That is huge as dress shoes usually hurt from the first few steps. The shoes are not smooth and slippery on the bottom either. The photo when I purchased these shoes made it look like the heel was 2 colors. It is actually a solid grey. The navy color is slightly lighter. Overall a great shoe. I would purchase these again.

Fit and sizing was good. The color leans more toward a royal blue than a navy blue.

This shoe is so cute and fit nicely and true to size. Unfortunately, the heel strap rubbed every step I took and I had to return them.

The fit and style were excellent. This is the second pair of the Mayetta that I've bought. Both are very comfortable. I worn to both pairs to a couple of events and danced all night in them without any added strain to my left ankle which is still healing. The only problem I had with the patent version was that it squeaked each time I walked. I didn't care for that. I wore it the next day to church and it squeaked less. Maybe it just needs breaking in. I'm going to order one in red and gold. These are my new go to shoes for the evening. Comfortable and stylish.

Perfect colour and I have multiple colours and these shoes are very comfortable

Cute! But stinky!!! I'm assuming it's the glue...whatever it is smells and was stinking up the entire closet until I put them in zippered plastic bags. I haven't worn these for long, but they are super cute and stylish. I am a size 12-13, so went with the 13 and am glad I did. I have the straps on the smallest hole, so I hope they don't stretch too much after wearing.

Loved this sassy little heel in bright red, the first time I saw them. I will say the toe is more pointed than I like, and that makes the fit around the top of my toes a little awkward and tight. Wearing hosiery helps, and I will probably add a pad in the bothersome area.

Beautiful shoe that is very comfortable. I did order a size up to accommodate for the pointy toe since I typically wear shoes with wider toe. The heel height was wonderful. I typically wear flats and these are a great compromise.

Cute shoe. I typically wear a 9M or 9W. I ordered both sizes in raspberry to match a dress. The photo shows the color correctly - it just didn't match my dress. There isn't much give to these shoes and neither size fit my foot good enough to keep. I have a bunion on my left big toe and it irritated the bunion. Otherwise, it's a cute shoe but probably not to wear for any long distance or time.

Almost kept these - pretty and unusual design on heel and low enough to walk comfortably; however, couldn’t get past the synthetic upper. Knew that when bought. Hoped it wouldn’t be relevant but feel a leather upper would be more comfy over time. Shame. Returned.

Comfortable heels

The width was too narrow, very tight on my toes

Too narrow at the toe end. Did not quite like the fit.

I think these shoes are stunning, but they were a little too narrow and a teeny bit small. I’d love to reorder a wider shoe but they are out of stock in my size.

I love the shoe but it is simply too small. I normally wear a 5 1/2 but this felt more like a 4!! Toe box is much too pointy to accommodate my foot and it felt much narrower than others I have. Would buy a size 6 but they are not available. Back to Zappos for more searching.

I am so sad. This is a lovely shoe that is very uncomfortable. The true blue color with subtle metallic sheen and cute heels perfectly matches my dress. I also like the mid-heel height with a wider heel that does not look chunky but would wear better. Unfortunately, the toe is more pointy than it appears in the photos and my toes just can't stand the tight squeeze - plus faux leather will not give.

Gorgeous shoe but shoe too narrow for my foot

Stylish with accent heel and good heel height but had to return. Toe box tight and although exchanging for C width and using gel pads helped, I couldn’t get over the hard plastic feel and lack of flexibility in the shoe overall.

Runs bigger than size.

Super beautiful. Toes were shoved into the pointy toe of the shoe. If the were just a little more comfortable I’d buy them! Love the heel.

Nice shoe with lovely heel detail, but too narrow for my wide foot even tho I ordered a wide width.

I ordered the 9.5 in red. The heel is so pretty and the shoe is very shiny and a gorgeous color. I sent them back because the sling back strap is narrow and would not stay on my heel. Super pretty shoes.

Style is great, but I could not get my foot into the shoe, nor was it long enough. Thanks Zappos for being a company that makes it a pleasure to shoe shop.

Loved the looks of this shoe. Got the red. Unfortunately, the narrow not narrow enough for my skinny heels. Also said there was extra padding in forefoot - in what world? Had to return. Will try again.

I love the look so much! The startup in the bank was too low though and did not keep the shoe on my feet as I walked. Had to return them.