Customer Reviews Earth Clare Earthies

Actually this show is a true 9B. Because I have a 9B in a similar style in Earthies, I thought they would fit the same. Probably the pair I have is an 8 1/2 N, which is what I am. A great show for a true 9B.

I LOVE THESE SHIES! Cute, stylish and great arch support!

This is a cute, attractive shoe. However the leather is a bit too stiff for my hammertoe. I regret I hve to return them.

Adorable shoe, but not quite wide enough for DD who only sometimes can fit in a normal width. Also, the back of the heel is quite high, but we couldn't get past the width to decide if it might be a problem.Too bad....

My usual 8.5 was much too tight in these shoes, especially for a recently-healed broken toe. I tried a 9 instead and decided to keep them, though only for special occasions (I'm a teacher, so I'm on my feet all day, and I think it wouldn't take long for these shoes to become pretty uncomfortable after a couple of hours. Then again, I've sworn off all open-toed and heeled shoes due to the injury). If you don't have foot problems, these shoes would otherwise be pretty comfy with their decent arch support and over-all design. I also love the neutral ginger print color - it goes well with a lot of business casual outfits.

Shoe was super cute and had a very comfy footbed, but the stretch bands over the top bothered me so I will be returning and ordering a different style. This may not bother someone else though.

I thought these were even cuter when I put them on than in the picture. However, they are too big, especially in the heel! I probably won't be able to go down a size since I wear a 12, and there is no such thing as 11 1/2. Size 11 would likely be too short for my left foot. Sadness. I appreciate Zappos for actually carrying size 12 women's shoes, but I get so frustrated with the limited selection and no 1/2 sizes. Not Zappos's fault, just the reality of the shoe market. Zappos's service was freakishly fast, as usual.

A very cute flat with enough rigidity in the sole to make it comfortable for walking. The elastic bands are a nice look, plus they keep a narrow-heeled foot like mine from slipping out of the shoe. I bought a different Earthies style last year and they are still comfy for dress wear, but too light in color for most of my clothing. Unfortunately, that style was no longer available, so I tried this one. They are very cute, and would feel comfortable, but my regular size, an 8M, is too short and cramped my toes, so back they go. I may try the next size, since I do like the shoe’s look.

I just received these in my usual size, 9.5. The length is fine, but they're a bit too wide but -- but the elastic holds them on. It's not snug at all, so a wider foot would probably love them. Also, the heel cup is a bit wide, so my heel slips a bit, but not much. The bit of toe cleavage is okay with me, and the cut misses my bunion completely, and so are comfy. I find the arch support about as good as Naots (of which I have a lot!). The ginger suede is totally neutral and interesting too. They make noise when I walk -- I think it's the removable insole. Not a lot, but more than none. Naots are not noisy at all. Not sure yet about the fit, but I want to find them okay and keep them -- they would be such a basic for spring wear!

I tried these shoes on in person before ordering from Zappos. The ones in the store fit a little bit loose but the ones from Zappos fit overall more snug. I believe that over time these shoes stretch more than usual, so keep that in mind when purchasing these. The blush color was nice and the the style is ok.

Very lightweight; pattern and color make it interesting but still neutral. I'd have loved to keep this, but the placement of the vamp means it cut right across my bunion. If you're fortunate enough to be bunion-free, this is a stylish shoe. Not really supportive, but nice and light on the foot.

Oh so cute! I love that companies are designing shoes with support that do not look like Grandma's orthopedics. But these didn't work for me. The area across the base of my toes is too tight. And no use trying to get a wider size since the heel area is already a bit loose. There is a nice supporting insole but the shoe didn't keep my foot correctly aligned in the footbed. I have a pair of earth sandals that fit and look great. But my search for a pair of nice looking flats continues.

I have a pair of Earthie Capri flats in size 9 that work very well for my feet and thought the fit on these shoes would be similar. However, for me, the same size in this shoe was a little loose, the toe box did not feel quite as generous, and the arch placement wasn't quite right for my foot. I ordered the ginger suede, which is a nice neutral, but it has a bit more glimmer than I wanted. For all those reasons, I decided to return them.

I received these shoes in in size 12 in the Blush color. I usually struggle into a size 12M because of a long big toe and a wide front of the foot. I loved the style but was dismayed to see that I was "swimming" in these shoes and even when I put my Vionic Orthotic inside it was way too large, so I sent them back.

Such a cute shoe, comfortable footbed and arch, but the elastic strapping is WAY too loose and sloppy, sits up above my foot. These are going back.

These are very cute, but for my feet, very strange arch support. I don't need and don't like arch support, and I have very high arches. But the arch support was so high, it felt like it was digging into my feet. Maybe this would have been fixed by going a half size larger, but I decided to return them. Too bad, because they really are cute.

These shoes are going to the back of the closet. Although they fit, and I like the style, they have several drawbacks. First, they mark the floor horribly - I haven't had shoes that do that for years, and didn't even think shoe soles were still made that would cause black scuffmarks everywhere you walk. I wore them to a job interview and was embarrassed. Second, the cut of the shoe makes it impossible to wear any kind of footie - even the low-profile ones will show; shoes are just not comfortable without footies in my opinion. Third, the footbed is not very wide or stable, and I tend to wobble on them if walking on a less stable surface. I can see a twisted ankle in my future. Fourth, and this is maybe unique to me, but they contain a metal bar in the footbed. As I have to pass through metal detectors regularly at my job, I have to take these off and run them through an airport detector. I work hard to avoid that, because it's a pain. So yes - back of the closet with these, unfortunately.