Customer Reviews Kelsi Dagger Brooklyn Logan Over the Knee Boot

I bought these after returning a cheaper pair of brown OTK boots. These boots are EXACTLY what I was looking for. Gorgeous suede, solid heel. Tried them on over skinny jeans, and they fit over my calves no problem. I usually can go either 7.5 or 8, but usually choose 8 for boots so I can wear thicker socks in the winter if desired. I went with the 8 and they fit great. I anticipate these to last a long time. I picked the chestnut just because I have been in a neutrals phase lately, but I would get them in every color if I could.

I love these boots! I am 5'5" and 145 pounds. I am athletic and have very strong legs and do not have tiny calves. (I believe I have 15" calf circumference) I have ordered and tried on boots before and they have looked way too tight but these are comfortable, cute, and they fit so well! I highly recommend them!

Ok, so at first I couldn’t get them past my calf!! I was devastated since I’d been looking for a pair this color and I LOVE this brand. So rather than curling up in a ball and crying, I kept trying. I didn’t think I had “large calves”??? I got them up by rolling them down kind of inside out and then tah-dah! All the way up and perfect. Just tight enough so they shouldn’t stretch or sag. Perfect.

These boots are gorgeous! I'm 5'3 and 106 lbs. The boots comes up to the middle of my thigh, which is higher than it would be on most women. They fit perfect from the foot to the thigh! I'm very small framed and I rarely find a pair of leg boots that are narrow enough to fit right, so these might not work for a wider set of legs. They are extremely comfortable to walk around in all day too. I absolutely love these boots ??!

These boots are gorgeous and well made BUT my calf’s are too big for them I am so very sad. Beautiful boots I wish they would have put some give in the calf part or made a few pairs to cover girls with calves.

This is my first air of over the knee boots. Love them. The boots fit like a glove and turn my "athletic" legs into "pins". My shoe size ranges from 7.5-8. I ordered both and kept the size 8.

I wanted to love this boot but it just didn't look or feel right. Unlike some of the other reviews I didn't have any problem getting the boot on. But once it was on I had one hell of a time getting it off. I didn't really care for where the half-zip ended. Made the boot feel like there was a bunch of extra bulk in the middle of my leg. Sadly I will be returning.

Great

I was looking for a grey boot, but these are more taupe/tan than true grey. The style and material is nice. The suede material is less “structured” than I’m used to wearing. This suede comes off as a little floppy, but I don’t think that would affect how they wear. They seem well made and would have been comfortable were I to have kept them. I thought they were a little on the big side. I usually wear a 9 1/2 in Dolce Vita and Franco Sarto tall boots. These felt maybe 1/2 a size too big. If I decide to order in another colour I’ll go with the 9.

If you're looking for a conforming type boot, this isn't it. The shaft height is true to description, and will go over your knee and to mid thigh, (I'm 5'6") it will be a looser, baggier fit at the top. Still looks great to wear and I still feel I've made a good decision on keeping these.

I LOVE these boots!!! I just opened the box and want to wear them out NOW even though it's past my bedtime ;)

I absolutely love these boots! They are just perfect. Casual but adds some sass and great heel height!!!!

Love these boots. I have wide athletic calves they fit well enough with stockings, but not wide enough for leggings or jeans. Very nice looking boots.

Size fit perfectly and the boot is comfortable to walk in. Sexy style!

Excellent buy! The boots fit great I can also wear under pants as well as over Leggings for extra warmth. I was not expecting that. Received the order very quickly as I do with all Zappos orders.

I loved these boots & got them in black. as one other reviewer stated, The ink coming off the inside of the boot was so bad! It was all over my legs. I even turned them inside out as far down as possible and put two coats of Scotchgard and the ink still came off very bad so I returned them. For reference, I am 5’2 105 pounds and have small calves, these boots had a little bit of room but fit good and stayed up.

A little loose around the knee but totally fashionable and comfy!

I have narrow calves so it's a struggle to find boots that work for me. These were too wide in the calves. Very cute and seem like they would be comfortable. But didn't work for me.

Love this boot. I’m pretty tall with very long legs. They barely hit Ive my knee, I wish they wear taller. I decided to keep them anyway. I will still love them.

I love the boots! Very cute! Were a little tight getting up the legs but I do have thicker calf/thighs so I’m sure it was more “me”

I wonder if my pair was defective. Other reviewers stated these were quite roomy. I have what I would describe as “skinny” legs and I couldn’t pull these up over my knee, they got stuck at my calf. Very sad to have to return them. They are really beautiful boots and the material feels lovely. The silhouette is on point, if only I could get them on.

I love these boots. The only thing is the left boot shaft at the top is loose. So as I walked around it did not stay up and close to my thigh. When I looked down it was loose and hanging down!!!! Very disappointed because they are so cute, stylish and comfortable. I did put in insoles for added comfort. So now I'm not sure If I'll return them or go to a cobbler to see if they can narrow the top of the boot shaft....I'm 5'7, 145 lbs, slim, athletic build so they may not fit that way for everyone... so I say try them...