Customer Reviews Steve Madden Feather Loafer Flat

Wanted to love these - but given the pointy toe they were oddly wide throughout the shoe. Tried going a size smaller and still had the same problem.

Super cute shoe but if you are a size 10, the shoe makes your foot look even longer. Sadly have to return them.

I loved the style, but even though I sized up, they were still tight and pinching near the toes.

Nice shoe, comfortable, but looks cheaply made for the price.

Cute but could never wear them at work

I was so disappointed that these were not keepers! The toe is just SO pointy - I really felt like an elf. Otherwise, very comfortable beautiful shoe. Just not for me!

Leather is super soft. However, they are super thin. I also thought I'd like the pointed toe, but as soon as I put them on, my son said they look like elf shoes! If you like the style and can fit an insert in them, they would probably be nice.

No arch support, looks comfortable when tried them on, but not until you walk around on these shoes that's when you feel the pain.

cheap

Cute if you have an office job to wear them at or wear for a cute look with minimal walking. Feels as if you are walking on the actual ground. Zero support,flimsy, the only reason you would want to purchase these is for a cute, clean,simple look. I normally wear a 10.5, bought an 11. They fit well, have some wiggle room in them,so hopefully no blisters and don’t smoosh my toes. If they start to stretch then my foot may slip out. Loafers especially should provide half sizes due to the style but unfortunately half sizes go quick when it comes to buying loafers in general.

I just have to be honest. These shoes looked and felt cheap. I returned them. Zappos should never deliver a shoe in a plastic bag with no shoebox. That should be saved for the clearance center. Disappointing overall.

I like the look of this shoe but could not get my foot in it. It was NOT true to size.

Materials were comfortable and flexible and the fit was good on my narrow feet, but the back of the shoe was sharp and rubbed on my heel so I had to return these.

These are not for flat feet! They look awful! Do not bother if you have flat feet!

Loved this shoe right out of the box, but when I tried them on the shoe on the right had a seam that was peeled back and dug into my foot. Expected better with this brand. They are going back.

Very nice looking at first. After one wear it looks as if the shoe is a year or more old. Very thin leather and the toe book creases almost instantly

I’m between sizes, 6.5-7. I ordered both in black to try and am returning both. The 6.5 fit but the back of the shoe felt stiff and the leather was hard and poking me. I only had them in for a minute and didn’t walk around but it was already a bit painful. I’m worried they won’t soften out and I’ll end up with a blister. The size 7 was too big. So if you’re between sizes go down and hopefully the pair isn’t as stiff as the ones I received.

That strange pointy toe: looks witchy. It even points up into the sky a bit! Sending back.

As much as I love SM shoes, these look and feel very cheap. I get it's a flat but there's NO support at all. The size is true to fit and color was perfect. A bit too wide for narrow feet and it only comes in medium and wide width. Will be returning

These are horrible! The material is subpar. The top/tongue immediately rubs the top of my foot! Ugly. Cheap looking and just awful!

I was really hoping for the best with these shoes. I have a wide toe box so I ordered a 10W in taupe croco. They were a little long but what really bothered me was, there was absolutely no structure or support and in combination with the pointy toe, my feet looked ridiculously wide. As a previous commenter wrote, they looked extremely cheap. They're going back! :(

I don’t know where to start to be honest. I ordered both pairs Black Leather and Tan Suede because they are adorable and I had a work trip planned to Chicago and knew I would be walking a lot. But these have to be knock off's. I wore the black pair on my flight and they were TERRIBLE to say the least, made out of cheap material that I could have purchased at Payless shoe or Walmart. Absolutely no flex in the body of the shoe- I don’t need support as I wear flats all of the time, but these shoes are the worst purchase ive made sadly. And now I am in a really hard spot because I spent $72/ pair on basically “vinyl” shoes. Sorely disappointed that Zappos would promote such a product. The price tag promotes a decent shoe and quality expectation, these however should not be a product that Zappos carries and if they are should be in the $20 price range and that would be overpriced

These are cruel shoes. My heels were bleeding after a 20 minute walk and two weeks later, still have visible marks from them that I assume will be scars. Are the backs of these made out of razor blades??