Customer Reviews Sperry Seaport Penny

These loafers are well made, like a proper loafer. The look is very tidy, and they don't gap in weird places when you walk. I would also add they are very comfortable, and the sole is not too stiff to walk in. I like that it's a gum sole, but from the side it looks like a leather sole.

This is a beautiful shoe. True to size. I have had these since 2021- so almost 5 years now. I wear them at least once a week to work since I’ve bought them. They are so comfortable. My only issue with them is do not get them wet! I had to run out to my car in the rain one day leaving work. They got totally soaked, and ever since then they stink! I’ve tried baking soda, shoe spray, all kinds of remedies, but they still have a smell after I wear them. So, beware! Or maybe wear them with liners or socks.

These were soft leather, true to size except the width. Very tight across the foot so unfortunately I have to return these! But I love the look and feel of them!

Beautiful shoe! Too small in the toe box for my toes.

This is a beautiful pair of shoes. I am truly sad that they were too wide for me. I also disagree with other posters who said to go up 1/2 size. The shoes were true to size.

Another great transitional shoe. These go with everything.

The left shoe fit perfectly but the right shoe was seemingly stretched out and slipped on my heel. So I'm returning and ordering another pair of the exact same size hoping that this time BOTH shoes will fit perfectly!

These shoes are just what I wanted for casual comfort. However, my size in every other brand of shoes is women’s 10. I ordered 10 in these and they were huge, so I sent them back for 9.5. However, the 9.5 are still just a smidge too long, but I fear the 9 would be too small. I’ve added a padded arch support inside and this makes them fit better. A smidge too big is better than too small I think. They are cute with jeans or casual pants.

This is a beautiful shoe- alas, I will be returning them because they make my feet look too big (to me). I wear a size 9. If I had smaller feet I don't think the size appearance would be a big deal, but for me at a size 9 it is a problem, unfortunately. The shoe is good looking, comfortable, and appears well-made.

These are my favorite pair of flats. I have the new black and the tan and love them both. They are a very soft leather and did not require any break in time. I have very low volume feet (flat top to bottom) and they fit my feet perfectly. I could see how they would be tight on someone with more heft to their foot or they would need to size up, but they fit like a glove on me. I usually wear an 8 and the 8 was too big in these and 7.5 fit perfectly without socks/liners. I also ordered the black/brown two-tone and while I liked them they weren't as comfortable due to the stiffer leather. I think they would be comfy over time, but unlike the softer leather ones, they would require some break in time. They have a nicely cushioned insole and I can wear them all day without foot pain, which is saying a lot because I have pretty severe foot issues. I wish the stitching wasn't a contrasting color, which is why I don't give the style a higher grade, but they are super comfy and versatile shoes. They're great year-round shoes for me in northern California.

I ordered these 1/2 size larger after reading reviews. Shouldn't have, they were too long, and too wide in the heel. Really liked the appearance, but had to return them.