Customer Reviews Sperry Seaport Penny

I have a narrow foot and these shoes are perfect for me. I own the black pair too.

I have these in the rose gold color in a 6.5 and they fit great and are comfortable. Last year I ordered the black patent leather in the same size and they ran much smaller. When I decided to order the navy patent, I ordered half a size up in a 7 and the fit is much better. Glad that I purchased them and will get a lot of wear out of them this fall/winter.

I work long days on my feet. These loafers are so comfy!

These are beautiful and so soft! I wish they fit. I'm normally a 6.5 and I couldn't even get the shoe on. Definitely size up, possibly a full size up.

Beautiful loafers! Just a tad too short so I ordered a half-size larger. Can’t wait to get them!

Extremely comfortable out of the box! I wore them to school, and felt energetic by the end of the day. This doesn’t happen if my feet hurt! I love the bright pink gold leather, too-

I am so happy with these shoes that I will be purchasing another pair in a different color. They are comfortable and stylish. I bought them to go with casual or work dresses and skirts since I can no longer walk around in high heels and they look great! I wear them without socks and I am able to to walk around all day in comfort. The black patent leather is easy to take care of - I just wipe the shoes with a damp cloth when they need it.

I loved the look of this shoe, but it felt much smaller than what I expected. I bought the Seaport Penny Heel shoe in the same size and they feel 100% different. The Seaport Penny is much narrower and shorter than the Seaport Penny Heel, both in size 8.5.

Runs 1/2 size too big. I always wear an 8 but these were too big. Love the soft leather. They are very comfortable. I could even wear them bare foot.

I have 4 pairs of Seaports I love them so much! However, a word of caution on which color/material you pick. Tan and Rose Gold are supple leather. So comfy, no break in period and I can wear them all day. Navy patent and black leather are super stiff. The black leather have been the worst so far which is so disappointing since they are such classics. Feel fine when you’re standing still but when you take a step, the top of the shoe presses down on the top of your foot quite hard. I can’t even imagine wearing them long enough to break them in, so I had to return. If they made them with more supple, flexible leather I’d happily purchase.

I LOVE these shoes and they are very cute! The pink loafer is super sharp and a very unique color with classic styling. Super comfortable shoe but felt 1/2 size too small for me. I normally wear a 9.5 and it was quite snug. I am returning for a size 10 hoping it will fit more comfortably. The only reason I gave it 4 stars instead of 5 is because I did not feel it ran true to size.

Great basic loafer, but toe box is a little narrow. Size up would be too large, but wide width not available.

I really love these sperrys and have them in multiple colors. Minus one star because the rubber sole began wearing away within the first few weeks exposing the hard plastic underneath. I've since taken them to have the soles replaced and everything is okay. These are soooo comfortable and appropriate for work in my office and walking approximately 3 miles each way to/from work.

I am normally a size 7, but had to reorder a size 7.5. These shoes definitely run narrow, but I have a narrow foot so they worked out fine for me. The grey color is great for spring and summer.

Although I typically wear a 8/8.5 in Sperry, I found myself keeping the 9. Tight, mostly is toe region, at first. Leather is soft and great quality!- Thus the price tag. Shoe appears to be stretching nicely and is very comfortable. You MUST give is just a little bit though. My INITIAL try on, I was doubtful if I was keeping the loafer or not. Just hoping it doesn't stretch too much being I am in a half size larger than I would normally wear. ( again, this is do to the shoe being a little more narrow in the toes). Note: I have a little bit wider than normal of a foot. ONLY down fall is the shoe does appear to look a little long. The grey is super cute. Dress up or down. Hope this helps!

Super cute shoe and probably would have been really comfortable. But I'm a true narrow width and these were too wide. Many review said they run narrow but I think now is that people ordering the wide width were saying they were not wide enough. Sadly, I'd have to really doctor them to make them fit my narrow feet so I returned them. But I'm still bummed as they keep popping up in ads and I think they are darling.

After reading several reviews commenting on this style’s tendency to run narrow, I decided to give it a try—I’ve worn a AA/AAA for most of my life, and I had been coming up empty while looking for a stylish/youthful/funky penny loafer in a narrow width. These shoes definitely run narrow, but that works out for me. My heels don’t slip, and there’s no big gap in the toe box like I frequently find with medium width shoes. The platinum is both fun and versatile. I’m looking forward to getting lots more wear out of these!

Love that these shoes are a beautiful, classic black patent. They started out far to tight and narrow, I have a bit of a wide foot. Always feel that if I buy good leather it conforms well and I usually am happy with the purchase, just have to break in. These are exactly the case. Wore them in clinic for a full day and by and of day they had stretched a bit and were much more comfortable. Think I'm going to love them!

Fit and comfort are great but the color was awful. In the picture it’s a pretty kind of orangish light brown with a sheen. In reality they’re a dull ugly brown that’s completely matte and not matte in a good way. Just really ugly and not even close to what the picture shows. Even with bright lights they wouldn’t have any shine to them so can’t blame this on the lighting or computer screen. Why anyone at Sperry thought this color or leather looked nice is beyond me.